NYT's Bruni: Anti-Vaccine Cause is the Left's Version of Climate Change Denial

As many on the left rush to pin the anti-vaccine movement on conservatives, liberal New York Times columnist Frank Bruni pointed out on Monday's CNN Tonight that the cause is actually more prevalent on the left side of the political spectrum: "I think a lot of the anti-vaccine people probably would hate to hear themselves lumped in with the climate change deniers. But they're doing the same thing from different places on the political spectrum." [video below]

Anchor Don Lemon brought up Bruni's January 31, 2015 column where he slammed the anti-vaccine cause:

DON LEMON: You write about this in an op-ed. It's called, 'The Vaccine Lunacy' – okay? You said, 'But what's in play is more than one – one affliction' – right? 'One affliction resurgence – the size and the sway of the anti-vaccine movement reflect a chilling disregard for science – or at least a pick-and-choose cafeteria approach to it. That's also evident, for example, in many Americans' refusal to recognize climate change.'

You think that these are the – sort of, 'natural' people who are promoting this – and, really, people of privilege who are promoting this?

Bruni didn't use ideological labels in his reply, but made it clear that he was targeting well-to-do liberals in his piece:

FRANK BRUNI, NEW YORK TIMES COLUMNIST: Yeah. You mentioned this – which is interesting – I think a lot of the anti-vaccine people probably would hate to hear themselves lumped in with the climate change deniers. But they're doing the same thing from different places on the political spectrum. They're basically saying, when my gut or when what I want to believe is different from science, I'm going to go with my gut and what I want to believe over science-

LEMON: Yeah-

BRUNI: And I think it happens across a spectrum of issues. I think it's a problem.

LEMON: Why are we seeing so many parents – especially parents, when you think of the – when you think of the 'natural' crowd, wouldn't you think that these are more learned people? Maybe I'm wrong.

BRUNI: Some of them are-

LEMON: Yeah-

BRUNI: But I mean – I think 'learned' is a term that can work in a lot of ways. They may be packed full of a lot of information. They may not be that bright about the way they process it-

LEMON: Yeah-

BRUNI: But you used the phrase 'all-natural,' and a lot of these people are the 'all-natural' crowd. If they really want to live 'all-natural,' are they getting dentistry for their kids? Are they getting orthodonture? I mean, 'all-natural' – when we lived 'all-natural' – you go back far enough – we were dying at 30 and 40. I don't think we really want to live 'all-natural.'

NB Daily Culture/Society Environment Global Warming Health Care Conservatives & Republicans Liberals & Democrats CNN CNN Tonight Video Frank Bruni Don Lemon
Matthew Balan's picture


Sponsored Links