In the end, economics is economics, and communist New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani (D) found that out the hard way during what would in most cases would have been a friendly interview with CNBC personality Andrew Ross Sorkin.
The Squawk Box co-anchor cornered Mamdani on his outrageous city-owned grocery stores proposal during the New York Times Dealbook Summit November 18.
“I do want to talk about supermarkets though,” Sorkin warned Mamdani. “This is an industry that typically has a margin between one and four percent and your plan is to sell products at a 30 percent discount,” he continued, with Mamdani nodding along like he’s getting ready to be offered up a softball question.
Sorkin then went for the jugular: “To the extent you were hoping, I think, to also force some other stores in the city and others to provide product at lower prices, how is this going to work at all? Just walk through the math when you think about it?” Before Mamdani could even utter a word, Sorkin hit him again: “And by the way, I understand the subsidy is coming from us, the taxpayer.”
Watching Sorkin getting Mamdani to give a non-answer about the economics of his stupid city-owned grocery store idea is must-see TV. https://t.co/Nea5m16l1n
— Joe Vazquez (@JV3MRC) November 19, 2026
Mamdani — completely caught off guard — rattled off incoherent gibberish that literally had nothing to do with explaining how his socialist precursor to breadlines made any mathematical sense:
When society deems something necessary for the public, then we subsidize its creation and operation. We know that so much of what we rely on for the public sector is not being paid for at price, whether it be the subway, or a public school, or a library, or sanitation, we have determined, ‘This is necessary.’ And when I think about what is necessary for a dignified life in New York City and anywhere frankly, it is very easy to come back to food, because we can’t live without it.
Talk about a word salad. Ironically, Mamdani’s own statement here is the strongest case against city-owned grocery stories. Here’s some math for Mamdani and his allies in liberal outlets like CNN who openly simped for his city-owned grocery store crock: According to an analysis by Empire Center President Zilvinas "Z" Silenas September 16, for the $90 billion that gets spent by New York on the public school system (roughly $37,000 per student), “New York’s fourth- and eighth-grade students’ performance in math and reading has been declining.” In fact, the New York Post editorial board reported in July that 906 of “out of 1,600 city schools” in NYC are “perennial failure factories” that continue operations with impunity, and they enroll about “43% of all NYC public school children.”
The “math” here begs the question how Mamdani applying a government cookie cutter method would make food any more accessible or sustainably cheaper in the same degree of effectiveness the city's public school system has on student performance. Well, no one knows the answer, because Mamdani didn’t even try to explain the operational math behind chicken-in-every-pot idea. Instead, he redrew the parameters of the question and answered a strawman:
When you were saying, ‘Explain the math to me.’ In some ways that’s the question New Yorkers are asking themselves every day when they go to the grocery store: ‘Explain the math to me of how the same thing that I used to buy a couple of years ago has now skyrocketed in price.’
Alexa, define inflation caused by runaway government spending. Sorkin, by simply asking a pointed question on the specifics on a pie-in-the-sky, forced Mamdani to reveal the underlying truth: Socialism and economics often make strange bedfellows.