During the third installment of PBS’s Crime and Punishment in America documentary on Wednesday, the assembled cast of narrators and talking heads lamented the rise in abortion restrictions following World War II. Such restrictions were portrayed as a step backward and an attempt at “regulating morals” and “regulating the status quo.”
Narrator Keith David began by hyping, “During the war, millions of women entered the workforce for the first time, filling jobs vacated by the men who had joined the military. American women were making money, learning new skills, and living very different lives than they had before the war.”
In PBS's "Crime and Punishment in America" documentary, historian Heather Ann Thompson claims that post World War II abortion laws were "as much about things like regulating morals, regulating the status quo." (1/2) pic.twitter.com/mD7caQ7HRX
— Alex Christy (@alexchristy17) November 19, 2026
MS NOW legal analyst Melissa Murray added abortion to the conversation, “Sexual mores are loosening. People are having sex outside of marriage. Single people are having sex. There's still a climate where access to contraception may be a little more uneven, but most women understand that if they find themselves requiring an abortion, there's a way to take care of it.”
David then recalled how “it had been a crime to perform an abortion in every state since the 1880s, but there had always been doctors and midwives willing to do the procedure. Unless their patients died, they were rarely prosecuted.”
Historian Heather Ann Thompson then asserted, “Crime completely depends on what moment we're in in American history. And it turns out that the criminal justice system is not just about public safety. It is, in fact, as much about things like regulating morals, regulating the status quo. And so after the war, when so many men come home from the war and there's a real return to this idea that we need to go back to more of the traditional family, women should get married now, they should have children, and so the criminal justice system is a place where you see this play out.”
David elaborated, “Now women who terminated their pregnancies were seen as a threat to the sanctity of the American family, even as communist subversives. And enforcement of abortion laws became much more common.”
Later, narrator Keith David lamented, "Now any woman seeking to end a pregnancy would have to take even greater risks." pic.twitter.com/mtcA86YuPn
— Alex Christy (@alexchristy17) November 19, 2026
Murray further decried, “Suddenly abortion becomes not just criminal but something that is deeply, deeply corrosive to society, and there's a crackdown.”
After some history lessons, David wrapped up the abortion portion of the show by reporting, “Now any woman seeking to end a pregnancy would have to take even greater risks.”
Whether it is talking about abortion in the 2020s or the 1940s, the media is always eager to echo the left and portray the issue as one of either as an argument between progressive abortion advocates and regressive pro-lifers. The actual question of when life begins is of much less interest and dismissed as “regulating morals” as if that would be a bad thing when talking about human life.
Here is a transcript for the November 18 show:
PBS Crime and Punishment in America
11/18/2026
8:38 PM ET
KETIH DAVID: During the war, millions of women entered the workforce for the first time, filling jobs vacated by the men who had joined the military. American women were making money, learning new skills, and living very different lives than they had before the war.
MELISSA MURRAY: Sexual mores are loosening. People are having sex outside of marriage. Single people are having sex. There's still a climate where access to contraception may be a little more uneven, but most women understand that if they find themselves requiring an abortion, there's a way to take care of it.
DAVID: It had been a crime to perform an abortion in every state since the 1880s, but there had always been doctors and midwives willing to do the procedure. Unless their patients died, they were rarely prosecuted.
HEATHER ANN THOMPSON: Crime completely depends on what moment we're in in American history. And it turns out that the criminal justice system is not just about public safety. It is, in fact, as much about things like regulating morals, regulating the status quo.
And so after the war, when so many men come home from the war and there's a real return to this idea that we need to go back to more of the traditional family, women should get married now, they should have children, and so the criminal justice system is a place where you see this play out.
DAVID: Now women who terminated their pregnancies were seen as a threat to the sanctity of the American family, even as communist subversives. And enforcement of abortion laws became much more common.
MURRAY: Suddenly abortion becomes not just criminal but something that is deeply, deeply corrosive to society, and there's a crackdown.
FEMALE VOICE: Chicago Daily Tribune: Mrs. Helen Stanko, 43, a midwife, was arrested yesterday by police, who said they found her in the act of performing an abortion in her home. Policemen made the raid after detailed preparation. They arrested nine women, one at a time, after they had left Mrs. Stanko's home, and took them to a medical examination. All made statements that Mrs. Stanko had just operated upon them.
MURRAY: Some police departments have a whole abortion squad, where their entire charge is to stake out abortionists and to crack down. So, you have raids of makeshift abortion clinics, where the police come in and there's literally a woman on the table with her dress up in the middle of a procedure, and she's taken into custody. Sometimes, pelvic exams are performed in order to determine that the woman was pregnant, so that you can actually establish that there was an attempted crime in progress.
DAVID: Doctors and midwives were arrested in high-profile raids, and their patients were compelled to testify against them. Some lost their licenses and were sent to prison.
MURRAY: When they are punished, when they are raided in such a public way, it sends a signal to other people doing this: You could be next.
DAVID: Now any woman seeking to end a pregnancy would have to take even greater risks.