The historical ignorance never ceases to amaze.
The other day President Trump had a historic “trilateral meeting” with Russia’s Vladimir Putin and China’s Xi Jinping. Suffice to say the media was all over it. And particularly when it came to Trump’s greeting of Putin, ABC late-night comedian Jimmy Kimmel was appalled.
Said Kimmel over Trump’s friendly greeting to the Russian, accompanied by an outstretched hand and also running a video clip of the President calling him “my friend”:
“How is that OK with anyone? Vladimir Putin is a terrible person. He’s a brutal dictator. He is a murderer. He kills people. He poisons them. He has them shoved out of windows.”
All of which displays an astonishing amount of historical ignorance of just what happens when an American President treats a Russian leader as Kimmel suggests when the two are featured at a summit sitting side by side.
Apparently Kimmel yearns for the good old days when President John F. Kennedy had his 1961 summit with the Putin of the day, Russia’s Nikita Khrushchev.
Thomas Hughes, an Assistant to Robert Kennedy, said this of the JFK-Khrushchev sit down in Vienna: “Despite all the briefings about what a crude, emotional peasant Khrushchev was, Kennedy couldn't have been prepared for what he was up against. Khrushchev thought of him as young, weak, ineffective, and probably a pushover. And Kennedy defended himself limply.”
Historian Timothy Naftali noted: “Khrushchev wanted Vienna to be humiliating for the American president. That was the goal. There was nothing that Kennedy could say or do at Vienna that would have derailed Khrushchev's strategy. Kennedy walked into an ambush.”
In short, with the Vienna summit ending the way Kimmel apparently believes this Trump-Putin summit should have, Kimmel ignores that with the Vienna Summit ending on a cold and sobering note the stage was set for the building of the Berlin Wall by the Communists. Not to mention Khrushchev placing nuclear missiles in Cuba, leading to the Cuban missile crisis that brought the globe close to an outright World War III. The fact is that the frigid JFK- Khrushchev relationship was portrayed in the media of the day - and correctly! -- as bringing America and the world to the brink of destruction.
In recent times, and I was privileged to be there as a young White House staffer, the decidedly anti-Communist President Reagan established and encouraged a friendship with Russia’s then-President Mikhail Gorbachev. As noted here at History.com:
“One was an avid capitalist, an actor-turned-U.S. president determined to quash America’s nuclear arms race with the Soviet Union’s “evil empire.” The other, a young committed communist who rose through the political ranks to lead the USSR, pushing publicly for reform.
But Ronald Reagan and Mikhail Gorbachev, unusual bedfellows as they may have been, managed to forge not only a mutual respect, but a friendship, which helped end the Cold War.
“I think, frankly, (that) President Gorbachev and I discovered a sort of a bond, a friendship between us, that we thought could become such a bond between all the people,” Reagan told journalists in Moscow during a visit in 1990.”
Going back in history even further there is the reminding tale of President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s Trump-style warmness to the Russian dictator of the day, Joseph Stalin. Stalin, without doubt, was eons worse of a brutal and murderous dictator than Putin. With FDR fondly calling Stalin “Uncle Joe.”
Back in 2015 The Christian Science Monitor did a review of a book titled Roosevelt and Stalin: Portrait of a Partnership, a detailed account of the World War II era partnership between the American President and his Russian counterpart.
Safe to say FDR, very much like Trump today, made a point of going out of his way to treat his Russian counterpart as a friend. As noted, FDR even referred to him warmly as “Uncle Joe.”
And there was a reason for FDR’s warm treatment of Stalin. Adolf Hitler’s Nazis were running rampant over Europe. If he was going to be defeated the realization was that the American President and Russian dictator (alongside Britain’s Winston Churchill) would have to work together to accomplish this. And so they did.
The hard fact of the matter is that while the world has turned since FDR and Stalin were friendly, in the world of human nature there is still rivalry and a potential for a globally dangerous animosity in the 21st century between the world’s “superpowers.” And as with FDR and Stalin, it is better - and safer - for the world today to have the leaders of America and Russia - and China too - working together as friends or at least allies rather than planning and plotting what could only turn out to be ruinous (and nuclear!) wars against each other.
Thus, for today’s media to be jumping on Trump for calling Russia’s Putin “my friend” betrays a historical reality that in fact another American President thought the same way of his then-Russian counterpart. And did so if for no other reason than that the world of that day needed the American President and Russian leader to both get along and unite to save the world from disaster.
The hard fact is that for there to be peace in this world the leaders of the United States and Russia - and China - need to get along. And without question when Presidents Roosevelt or Reagan or Trump are able to establish a friendship with their Russian counterpart, the world is better off. And when that not only doesn’t happen but is decidedly not good - as was the relationship with JFK and Khrushchev at that Vienna Summit- today’s modern world can literally be endangered with the threat of nuclear war. And the media will be there to spread the news.
In short? President Trump has made an apparently successful effort to establish a friendship with Russia’s Vladimir Putin. And while this or that American media personality may not like it, (like Jimmy Kimmel!), the world is infinitely safer and better off because of it.
And one suspects both Putin and Trump know it. Even if Jimmy Kimmel or anyone else in the media doesn’t get it.