CNN's Michael Smerconish Shows What a Patriotic Moderate Looks Like

November 17th, 2026 12:55 PM

On Saturday morning, CNN host Michael Smerconish offered a reminder of what a patriotic political moderate can look like, showing that being involved in partisan politics does not mean abandoning love for America. He cited a survey which found that too many young people believe America deserved 9/11. Smerconish ended by urging students who believe America deserved 9/11 to remember its victims, emphasizing, “No, never forget.”

Smerconish began the segment by sharing a disheartening statistic from The Buckley Institute’s survey: “22 percent of all students, more than one in five, agree with the statement, America deserved September 11th.” He confessed that the survey hit him “so hard” when he read it especially since he was going to interview Navy SEAL Rob O'Neill, the man who killed Osama Bin Laden.

 

 

Smerconish recalled that during the interview, O’Neill discussed “his career, over 400 missions, more than 50 decorations, and of course, the raid at Abbottabad.” Smerconish shared that “It was one of the most memorable interviews that I've ever been privileged to conduct.”

Returning to the survey, Smerconish noted that “today's undergraduates, they didn't live through 9/11, so they can't know the feeling of it happening in real time.” He emphasized that “if we let our guard down” then an event like 9/11 “could certainly happen again.” He wondered “And if it did, will those students feel they're at fault?”

During that interview, Smerconish invited two special guests, Ellen Saracini and Tara Bane, who brought her son to meet O’Neill. Ms. Saracini was “widowed on 9/11 when her husband, Victor, the captain of the United flight 175, was killed when the hijackers took over and flew the plane into the South Tower.” Ms. Bane was “30 when she lost her husband, Michael, who worked on the 100th floor of the North Tower.”

Both women tearfully thanked O’Neill for what he had done. Ms. Saracini gave him a 9/11 Never Forget pin and Ms. Bane's son asked him to autograph his Bin Laden wanted poster. Smerconish admitted that he “was a bit overcome with emotion myself” as he watched these women interact with O’Neill.

Smerconish ended with a powerful declaration to students: “To those college students who think that America deserved 9/11, I ask this, what did Ellen Saracini or Tara Bane do to deserve losing their husbands? No, never forget.”

Click Expand to view full transcript:

CNN's Smerconish

November 14, 2026

MICHAEL SMERCONISH: Earlier in the program, you met Ben Sliney. He was the head of FAA operations on September 11th, his first day on the job, and he closed all of the American skies single handedly, much like what happened yesterday.
Well, check this out. The Buckley Institute's 2026 survey of undergraduates was released earlier this week, and it's revealing and more than a little distressing. Among the results, one particular number caught my eye, 22 percent of all students, more than one in five, agree with the statement, America deserved September 11th.

It hit me so hard. Maybe because the very day I read the survey, I was about to go interview Navy SEAL Rob O'Neill, the guy who killed Bin Laden. And I did it that night, Wednesday night, in front of a rapt audience, I questioned him for 90 minutes.

We talked about his career, over 400 missions, more than 50 decorations, and of course, the raid at Abbottabad. It was one of the most memorable interviews that I've ever been privileged to conduct. It was done live on C-Span. It's now available on my YouTube channel.

Of course, today's undergraduates, they didn't live through 9/11, so they can't know the feeling of it happening in real time. And here's hoping that they never will. Because if we let our guard down, it could certainly happen again. And if it did, will those students feel they're at fault? I wish they could have been in the green room before my interview with O'Neill.
It was there that I told Rob that I had two special invited guests who wanted to shake his hand. Into the room came Ellen Saracini. She was widowed on 9/11 when her husband, Victor, the captain of the United flight 175, was killed when the hijackers took over and flew the plane into the South Tower. She gave O'Neill a 9/11 Never Forget pin. He wore it during the interview.

And then came Tara Bane. She was 30 when she lost her husband, Michael, who worked on the 100th floor of the North Tower. She was tearful when she thanked O'Neill. She brought her son, Cole, who asked him to autograph a Bin Laden wanted poster.

Watching these women, I was a bit overcome with emotion myself. And to those college students who think that America deserved 9/11, I ask this, what did Ellen Saracini or Tara Bane do to deserve losing their husbands? No, never forget.