Plante: "The White House says that the defense secretary hasn't discussed resigning with the president and the president isn't about to fire him. Of course if the president did, he'd be admitting that he had failed."
CBS Early Show co-host Julie Chen apparently thought Plante’s logic was unassailable. She replied, "That's a good point." At 7:08AM EDT, co-host Harry Smith interviewed John Batiste. Smith provided an almost nonstop barrage of softball questions for the retired general. One might have mistaken the tone for a Katie Couric interview with Jimmy Carter:
Smith: "First off, the most important reason, single most important reason you think Secretary Rumsfeld should resign?"
Smith: "Were you frustrated in that system?"
Smith: "And I just get the sense from looking and reading the, uh, the, the opinions from you retired generals who want Rumsfeld's resignation that he just was literally just not listening enough."
Finally, Smith preceded a rambling question by indicating that Rumsfeld should have simply listened to him:
Smith: "You know, it's interesting, because we've interviewed the secretary here and one of the issues that, right from the beginning of the war, are there enough troops on the ground, do you have what you need to effectively fight this war effectively, to win the peace. He said, well, I'm relying on my commanders on the ground and, and we suggested to him, well, maybe your commanders are telling you what you want to hear. Does that ring true to you, at all, as a scenario that happened over the last three years?"
Count Harry Smith among the retired generals who are ready and willing to give Donald Rumsfeld advice, if only he’d ask.