Fort Lauderdale Sun-Sentinel Editor's 'Answer' to Web Challenge

  • Bookmark and Share

Sometimes watching the MSM grapple with the challenges of web journalism can produce some quite funny results. Such was the case with the editor, Earl Maucker, of my hometown newspaper, the Fort Lauderdale Sun-Sentinel, as he attempted to explain how his newspaper was dealing with that newfangled thing called the Internet. In his reponse to the question on how the Internet has affected the newspaper business, Maucker provides a pollyannaish response with Web offers new visual dimension:

Instead of focusing primarily on the written word, along with photographs and graphics, as seen in our traditional printed products, we now offer a wide array of video, animated graphics and detailed data bases online to accompany our stories.

Our newest entry into this world is animated editorial cartoons done by our cartoonist Chan Lowe, but I'll get to that in a moment.

How about if we get to Chan Lowe's animated editorial cartoons right now, Earl? Just one look at Lowe's artificially animated cartoon made me burst out laughing, and not because of the intended content of the cartoon itself. The laughter came from the incredibly pathetic attempt to animate what is supposed to be a static cartoon. I'm not privy to Chan Lowe's inner thoughts but my guess is that he absolutely HATES the ridiculous animations you are forcing upon his cartoons. Maucker continues on excitedly describing the window dressing he is adding to the Sun-Sentinel to meet the challenge of the Web:

No area has been more impacted than visual journalism, where the addition of animation and video has opened new vistas to our staff and our online audiences.

Talented journalists in our graphics department, for instance, have been enhancing charts, graphs and other elements through audio and visual techniques that make the material truly interactive.

Graphics! Why that's just the thing to answer the challenge of the Web and the plunging newspaper circulations that Maucker carefully avoids in his pep talk. But wait! There is an exciting new feature in the Sun-Sentinel to take advantage of that Internet thingie:

To take advantage of the web capabilities, our editorial page editors created "The Slant", a blob devoted to opinion and commentary that goes well beyond what we offer on our printed editorial and commentary pages.

"Blob?" It seems like a typo but is it really? I've seen "The Slant" and it is indeed a formless boring blob. Perhaps this is why the Sun-Sentinel editors are hiding it from the readers since you can't even find a direct link to it from the front page. Maucker goes on to describe the new blob via his editorial page editor:

The guiding philosophy behind The Slant, says Editorial Page Editor Antonio Fins, is to give our readers more than just an electronic copy of what is available in the paper.

So what is the story at the very top of The Slant blob that is "more than just an electronic copy of what is available in the paper? It is Florida braces for another special session which breathlessly reports:

 Don't be surprised to see Democrats in the Florida Senate push for some re-evaluation of tax cuts and sales tax exemptions to help lawmakers close a yawning budget shortfall that right now is around $1.1 billion.

Yawning is right. But, hey, this is more than just an electronic copy of what is available in the newspaper. I mean, this story adds some sort of new dimension way beyond what can be offered in mere print...according to Maucker. Finally Maucker returns to the subject dear to him---the cartoon animation shtick as explained by Antonio Fins:

 "We didn't settle for simply posting Chan's editorial cartoons. Instead, we've chosen to take advantage of the Internet's capability by putting motion into them, giving Chan a chance to be even more creative."

Yup! The Slant "blob" and animating static editorial cartoons with unintentionally hilarious results are going to somehow save the Sun-Sentinel from the Internet onslaught. Thanks for the humor, Earl, and for a comedy encore permit me to present that Chad Lowe animated cartoon again.

 

—P.J. Gladnick is a freelance writer and creator of the DUmmie FUnnies blog.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

ROTFL

Didn't expend much effort in animating that comic, did they?  If that's the best they can do, they're in big trouble.  Especially if this comment is serious:

"...the addition of animation and video has opened new vistas to our staff and our online audiences."

My 'animation'

Hey Earl! How's my animation below?

W          M     

(Look at the W then look at the M quickly back and forth. Look! It's flipping over and over! Tee-hee!)     

Wow! Every 80 year old out there will be amazed!

I disagree with P.J. on his assumption that the cartoonist must be embarrassed with this 'animation.'

The subject of the cartoon itself was an old, lame joke.

I feel like subscribing to the Sun-Sentinel just so I can cancel it.

Newspapers will begin

Newspapers will begin disappearing in about 5 - 7 years and most will be extinct in 15 years.

Couldn't happen to a nicer crowd.

Newspapers

Actually newspapers have one IMPORTANT asset that for some bizarre reason they are not taking advantage of even though it is PERFECT for the Web. I actually e-mailed last year the then Miami Herald editor, Tom Fiedler, with an idea on the best way to use this asset last year and he responded right away that he was very interested in it. Then he tossed the project off to the Herald's online editor and it pretty much died with him. The online editor also agreed that it was a great idea but claimed he "didn't have the resources" to try it out. Resources? Any college intern at that newspaper with a good knowledge of software could have set the whole thing up within a week on an experimental basis. What the real problem was that the online editor was scared of rocking the boat with a (GASP!) new idea.

This is something that ONLY a newspaper can do. It amazes me they haven't taken advantage of an asset that almost all of them have. And, no, I won't reveal that asset here. Or at least at this time. However, if Earl Maucker wants to hear me out on this... It is my hometown newspaper and sure beats those silly animated cartoons.

Dang...

If Fiedler dislikes it (old pre-high-mucketymuck foe) that automatically makes your idea very interesting to me...
JMR

Rally online with fans of Dr. Ron Paul.

Fiedler

Actually Fiedler LIKED the idea quite a bit. The problem is that he tossed it off to the Herald online editor (who also like the idea) but who was worried about rocking the boat with a completely new idea. The idea didn't have anything to do with politics but was an innovative way of using something most big newspapers have yet, astonishingly, have not made much use of. Leaving out the details, it was a way of getting back readers that have long ago quit reading the newspaper.

Ah, I see

You'd think something like valuable enough paper coupons would retain readers, but that's traditional and it hasn't worked. Now I'm trying to figure-out the idea! :)

I sometimes just give away my "good" ideas in hopes that someday they'll benefit me. For example, all cellphones have a battery but none of them (AFAIK) have added the 3 cent LED that would make them flashlights, so I have to carry around one of those mini-LED flashlights on my keys. I want my phone to be a flashlight too. The technology has existed for decades, and it's not like my idea is a stroke of genius...
JMR

Rally online with fans of Dr. Ron Paul.

Cell Phone Flashlight

For example, all cellphones have a battery but none of them (AFAIK) have added the 3 cent LED that would make them flashlights, so I have to carry around one of those mini-LED flashlights on my keys.

 Um, actually my Nokia cellphone DOES have a mini-LED flashlight.

sad

Newspapers might disappear, but the sad thing is that liberals will never disappear.

NEVER,NEVER trust a "liberal"