MSNBC.com Pumps Up Bias, Shows Gas Price 21 Percent Above Average

Photo of Ken Shepherd.

NewsBusters.org | MRC.org | screencap of MSNBC.comIt's a common trick the media employ when reporting on "skyrocketing" gas price stories: show photos or B-roll of price marquees that bear prices way above the actual average price.

MSNBC.com's front page this morning is no exception, as the screen cap at right shows regular unleaded for $3.979, or 21 percent higher than the national average of $3.27.

The article's headline reads, "Rising gas costs crimping budgets."

The caption for the same photo in the article reads, "Gas prices already top $4 a gallon at many stations including this Shell outlet in Menlo Park, Calif."

Menlo Park is a suburb of San Francisco and as of March 20, 2008, regular unleaded prices there averaged $3.73/gallon, compared to $3.27 nationally and $3.67 in Northern California.

For more on the media's biased reporting on gasoline prices, check out the Business & Media Institute's special reports "Gassing Up" (May 9, 2007) and "Gas Hysteria" (Sept. 26, 2006), as well as their archive of daily analysis on energy reporting archive here.

Photo in screen cap is AP file photo by Paul Sakuma


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Why pile on?

$3.27 is bad enough. Why the need to inflate it? Answer: it just accelerates their preferred conclusion ...

... which means they just can't wait for it to happen. They want to make it happen faster. Wonder why?

Of course, it also shows that Democrats and liberals can't win unless things are really bad. And when Obama and Clinton keep screwing themselves, it puts pressure on liberals to make things seem even worse. It's pathetic, really.

Menlo Park, CA. That

Menlo Park, CA. That explains it all.

Hey, they should be glad. Libs have said for years we have it too easy, we should be paying $5 a gallon like they do in Europe. So what's the problem? The problem is that it's because of the law of supply and demand; not a "penalty" that they have gotten imposed to teach us a lesson.

And did you ever notice they always feature CA prices, but never discuss why gas is so high there? And how much does CA actually bring up the national average? What would it be without CA prices?

good point

And I've forgotten ... anyone know how much consumption tax California imposes? They add taxes to make you stop driving so much, but then they complain that gas prices are too high.

Remember the movie Sybil, about the little girl with multiple personalities? That's how you have to talk to liberal legislatures: "I want to talk to the faction in there who raised taxes ... hello? hello? Am I addressing the tax raisers?"

"And did you ever notice

"And did you ever notice they always feature CA prices, but never
discuss why gas is so high there? And how much does CA actually bring
up the national average? What would it be without CA prices?"

Bingo. I was about to type the same thing, until I saw your post.

Let them put gas prices up higher, then we'll drill Anwar!

I say let them show higher than average gas prices.  We'll elect Repubs and then get to drill ANWAR!

taxing gas solution

That's not their solution though. Rather than get more oil they wish to create a 50 cent per gallon gas tax. Also, Anwar can not be drilled because the barren waste must be ecologically persevered.

I don't agree with their solution or their view of Anwar but it does show there's no problem that can't be made worse. Anwar would certainly help but we need to figure out how to wean ourselves off foreign oil. I do not know how that can be accomplished. Any ideas?

m1xram

Some ideas

Well, there's Anwar like you said, but we'll have to prepare for the whining, crying, and theatrical protests from the usual unemployed, uswashed enviro-activists who will use the usual, tiresome, silly protest routines:  human chains, throwing themselves in front of equipment, blocking entrances/exits, smearing themselves with fake blood, burning effigies of GW Bush and Dick Cheney even though they were long out of office, etc.

Then we need to drill offshore....all of our offshore real estate where oil and natural gas is present....and get those resources before the other "developing nations" around the world suck them dry.

We need to uncap those wells in Texas and elsewhere that have been capped for about 20 years and use those resources.  I mean, they're ours and they're on our soil just waiting to be used.

We need to build NEW refineries for gasoline production and NEW nuclear power plants for the production of electricity.  Guess what? this would also create jobs and economic growth.

This is the really difficult area: we need to find conservative policians who will implement these things, and who have the moxie to tell the environmentalists, eco-socialists, and other anti-capitalists to go to hell.  We must elect people who have distain for the Kyoto treaty. 

We must make certain that environmental activists are never again allowed to set energy policies or to bully lawmakers with their anti-common sense agenda that contributed to our dependence on foreign oil.

That's a start.  Yes, we need "change".  This is "change".

I have a question

When they show "the most expensive gas in the U.S." I just have one question... who's buying their gas there? I mean, you know that you could go anywhere else and your gas will be cheaper. The gas station knows that everyone else is going to go somewhere else.

I'd like to know the price of their gasoline on the day after the media touts them as the most expensive gas in the U.S.

*****

"People only insist that a debate stop when they are afraid of what might be learned if it continues." - George Will 

Rental cars

I see much higher than usual gas prices near airports. The reason is that people are usually in a hurry to get there and must have their rent car full when they return it. Personally, I've had more than one experience when I was on half a tank in my rental and had 15 minutes to turn in my car and get to the ticket counter. I had no choice but to pay the outrageous prices at the gas station there by the airport.

 



"To send men to the firing squad, judicial proof is unnecessary." Ernesto "Che" Guevara


Why not remove the taxes on Gas and drop the price 47 cents?

- The average amount of tax on gasoline in the United States is 47 cents per gallon (API)
- The average amount of tax on diesel in the United States is 53.6 cents per gallon (API)

Then again the media has never been able to adjust for inflation.

Give me a break - Oil Prices (Video) (5min) (John Stossel, 20/20)

The Anti 'Man-Made' Global Warming Resource

Never happen! So let us DRILL ANWAR! SAVE THE HUMANS!

It's time as enviromentalists WE SAVE THE HUMANS!  The birds and caribou will survive also!

Drill often...Drill

Drill often...Drill everywhere! 

"Never murder your opponent when he is committing suicide." ~ W. Churchill

Caribou

I'm glad you mentioned the caribou. The green crowd claimed that they would not go near the pipeline. It turns out that the caribou are very opinionated about the subject. They like the pipeline! The air currents around the pipeline help keep the flies off them. Ever watch a caribou migration show? The flies in spring get to be about 100 per cubic foot.

m1xram

Rep. John Dingell,

Rep. John Dingell, (Dingbat, Mich.) is currently proposing a $0.50/gal tax hike.

He claims he wants to encourage conservation. Right.

Great timing, don't ya think?

Theme for Election '08: I want my mommy!

Yeah, that's an idea that will fly

He might as well call his proposed idea the "Political Suicide Bill"

 So, according to liberals the answer to high gas prices is to make it even higher. You can't make this stuff up.

He won't

have to worry about not being re-elected. He is from the Detroit area of Michigan. They keep electing the same liberal, high taxing, big spending Democratic politicians and wonder why the Formerly Great State of Michigan is in the toilet. Gas prices around here are alread averaging 3.20/gallon. They don't need to be higher.

MichiganMan,

As a resident of the state of Georgia, I fully understand your frustration.

Two words: Cynthia McKinney. :-O

Theme for Election '08: I want my mommy!

Isn't Michigan in enough

Isn't Michigan in enough trouble? Has the Honorable Mr. Dingell suggested what the State of Michigan will be doing with the "windfall profits" from such a tax?

 

I am the exotic Queen Mum, and I approved this message.

Well, RD, that's how libs

Well, RD, that's how libs think. I said above they don't like increases caused by supply/demand, but if they impose a penalty, that's fine. And within minutes of me writing that, I read down further, and find your post. (I didn't see it before, I swear!)

So high prices aren't enough to make people conserve, Mr. Dingell? They have to know it's a "consumption tax" to make it work?

Where's my flippin' duct tape????????

motherbelt,

LOL-Don't worry about it. In the old days here, stepping on other's posts was somewhat frowned upon, as there weren't that many posters at the time.

Nowadays, it has gotten rather crowded, so most of us don't have time to read every thread, particularly post by post. KWIM?

Theme for Election '08: I want my mommy!

In addition to that, the

In addition to that, the Fox News story quotes the moron who thinks we should raise gasoline taxes by 30 cents per gallon, a year for 10 years! That's a $3.00 increase in taxes over ten years! That's not including the 47 cent a gallon average state and federal tax we already pay! (I remember when it was 9/10's of one penny!)

Under this nimrod's plan, the taxes on gasoline, would equal the price of gasoline itself! Providing we have enough sense to drill for our own oil. That's what the Europeans have to contend with. Didn't we fight a revolution over this stuff?

Of course the moonbat says this tax increase would be offset by a decrease in income tax.(yeah, right) But what about poor folks, and folks on disability and Social Security? Many of those, including the working poor, pay no income tax. You've just doubled the cost of their gasoline, which they HAVE to buy in order to go to work and feed their families, with no relief!

More and more I think we need to send everyone of these liberal to Gitmo.

God help us all.

 

Once a year

That's a solution they propose ever year. Clinton, Kerry, etc have all "invented" that one. For extra credit, please list all those who have propose a gas tax. I'm guessing there are at least 10 congress people who have done so.

m1xram

And the Congress people who

And the Congress people who propose this nonsense should be waterboarded until their attitude improves.

Ever notice how liberals want to tax or to ban anything they don't like?

No matter what the prices

No matter what the prices are for gasoline, if you don't like them you have a chance this November to fire your representative and selectively your senator(s). They are the ones that brought you the bogus "Energy Bill" that does nothing to bring in more supply or process it. But, hey, you can stave off bogus "global warming" by buying those mercury laden CFL lightbulbs. In fact, in a few years, you won't be able to buy anything else!!!

Gald I'm not average

I just paid $2.89 a gallon yesterday when I filled up here in Minneapolis. I'm sure glad I'm not average!

Minnesota's Dems hike gas tax

Enjoy it while you can, CobraMan. As I'm sure you know, your Democrat-dominated legislature recently overrode Republican Gov. Tim Pawlenty's veto and rammed through a huge increase in gas taxes.

I feel for you.

When you put the clowns in charge, don't be surprised when a circus breaks out.

Thanks

Yea, thanks for reminding me.

They raised the gas tax to pay for "urgently needed highway and bridge maintenance" yet failed to mention that our legislature only approves a budget once every two years. That’s if we're lucky enough to actually get a budget agreement that soon, it usually takes several "special sessions" which increases our legislators’ per diem and travel payments but accomplishes little else. The way our state government works, any "improvements" won't be paid for until at least 2010. Just how "urgent" can these repairs be if it's going to take at least two years to raise the "necessary " funds?

The truth is, all the increased tax revenue will be used to fund everything BUT highway maintenance since the money will go directly into the general fund. I guess a gas tax increase sounds better than an income tax increase even though the effect will be the same. The worst part? Several “Republicans” think this tax increase was necessary! I guess they needed more pork before the next election.

Here's a state by state

Here's a state by state list of gasoline taxes.

http://www.gaspricew...

Tax List Is Old

Not too sure how much I'd trust that list, since it's from 2005. I don't have a better one, though.

Edit: Ok, I lied :o) Here is the 1/1/2008 report

V/R
Clyde 

"...the aspirants to tyranny are either the...men of the state, who in democracies are demagogues,... or those who hold great offices, and have a long tenure.." - Aristotle, Politics, c350BC

The problem may soon be over

Here is yet another way of getting hydrocarbons from waste.

This company has been in operation for a few years now and are in effect taking waste products and running the "manufacturing process backwards" to get raw materials including oil, gasoline, chemicals, etc.

The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.

This is completely in line

This is completely in line with my theory of the "media-created recession."

A lot of our economy is based on confidence. If the markets aren't confident, stocks fall. It is, after all, "speculation" on whether a given stock will be profitable. And our own spending is based on the confidence that we can afford a big purchase. If we're worried about our job, our income, then we decide to save it for a "rainy day."

The stock market and consumer confidence and spending are some of the biggest drivers of our economy. So.... if you convince enough people we're heading for a recession, I believe you can actually create one, and we're seeing it now. The libs have been crying "recession" for at least a year now, and economists are saying we're finally almost there.

Self-fulfilling prophecy.

You know how in the army

You know how in the army they shell a position for a while, and then send out recon aircraft to assess the damage?

Well the MSM talk "recession" for a month, then they send out their pollsters to see what effect they've had. If they've succeeded, the pollsters come back with the damage report, and Bingo! They report that "consumer confidence is down." (meaning they are on target.)

If confidence isn't down, they step up their attacks: look for job losses, worried families, even someone who's putting off buying a car until next year...then after a while the pollsters go out again.

Gas prices

Yes they always find the highest priced gas station to indicate the crisis. They never say that the dims ran as part of their 2006 campaign that given a majority in congress they would  do something about $2.50 per gallon of gasoline. Well they obviously have! According to this article by the dims official mouth piece it is now $4.69.

This is just nitpicking Ken

Ken,

With all due respect oil prices are the highest they have every been and it is taking a toll on many people. Every time oil prices go up by then dollars barrel. The msm is exaggerating. If a barrel of oil goes down by 2 dollars. Most at NB are saying the msm is not reporting it properly.

Will it take 5 dollar a gallon prices for NB to admit oil prices are out of control and they are effecting peoples way of life?

Oil Prices are only as high as they were in the 80s

It is easy not to adjust for inflation. If you are concerned about the toll the prices are taking on people then you should push for the removal of the 47 cents a gallon tax, the removal of regulation to allow for new refineries to be built (none have been built since 1976) and drilling anywhere and everywhere. Supply and Demand. 

The Anti 'Man-Made' Global Warming Resource

huge difference Popular Tech

Gas in the 80s was expensive, but it came down after a while. The price for gas has gone up every year since the Bush adminstration took over and there is not a end in site.

Bush has nothing to do with Gas Prices, China's demand does

Bush did not raise taxes, restrict supply or implement price controls on oil. The price is a direct result of supply vs demand. China's oil demand has gone up every year Bush has been in office

- China is the world’s second-largest consumer of oil behind the United States (EIA)
- China's oil consumption is increasing nearly a half million barrels per day (EIA)

The Anti 'Man-Made' Global Warming Resource

popular tech

I never said Bush was responsible did I? I said it has gone up ever single yr since he has been in office. NB seems to think the msm is exaggerating the price of gas. I disagree and think it is a outrageous price right now.

 

The MSM is exaggerating the price

If you do not adjust for inflation then yes they are exaggerating the price. The price is only outrageous if you do not adjust for inflation.

The Anti 'Man-Made' Global Warming Resource

53 cents a gallon

When I got my first car, gas was 53 cents a gallon (and please don't call me old!). That price has risen just about every year since then. Fortunately for me, my income has risen at just about the same rate as the gas prices so the effect on my bank account has remained about the same.