NewsBusters
Published on NewsBusters (http://www.newsbusters.org)

Home > NYT's Egan Finds Trump Inevitable 'Monster' of Racist, Vet-Smearing, Birther GOP

NYT's Egan Finds Trump Inevitable 'Monster' of Racist, Vet-Smearing, Birther GOP

By Clay Waters | July 26, 2015 | 1:43 PM EDT
Share it Tweet it
0
shares

Timothy Egan, who wrote liberal screeds for the New York Times as a reporter before finding a more fitting habitat as one of the paper's stable of left-wing anti-Republican columnists, piled on the GOP's current presidential front-runner in "Trump Is the Poison His Party Concocted," in the paper's Sunday Review.

It's a back-handed defense of the controversial real estate mogul, suggesting that Trump is only the inevitable end result of toxic GOP racism and attacks on war heroes like....John Kerry?

Egan strung together some out-of-context political events from over the last dozen years while leaving out the parts that would spoil his anti-Republican narrative. He trusted his readership either would not remember the details, or (if they're loyal Times readers) had never read about them in the first place.

The adults patrolling the playpen of Republican politics are appalled that we’ve become a society where it’s O.K. to make fun of veterans, to call anyone who isn’t rich a loser, to cast an entire group of newly arrived strivers as rapists and shiftless criminals.

....

They say he’s trashing the Republic brand. They say he’s “stirring up the crazies,” in the words of Senator John McCain. But Trump is the brand, to a sizable degree. And the crazies have long flourished in the Republican media wing, where any amount of gaseous buffoonery goes unchallenged.

....

Trump is a byproduct of all the toxic elements Republicans have thrown into their brew over the last decade or so -- from birtherism to race-based hatred of immigrants, from nihilists who shut down government to elected officials who shout “You lie!” at their commander in chief.

....

Consider Trump’s swipe against McCain’s military service, and by extension all veterans who have been involved in the fog of combat. Republicans were apoplectic at Trump’s claim that McCain was no war hero.

Egan teed himself up by quoting Jeb Bush saying "There is no place..." for such comments, then swung:

No place except a presidential campaign, that being the 2004 attempt to destroy the honorable Vietnam service of candidate John Kerry. Where was Bush’s “respect and admiration” when his brother was benefiting from a multimillion-dollar smear of a Navy veteran with a Bronze Star and a Purple Heart?

Yet Egan ignored how that "smear," from a group of Kerry's fellow soldiers, The Swift Boat Veterans for Truth, knocked some major holes in Kerry's hero story when he attempted to use it to gain the presidency in 2004, to the sharp dismay of the Times, which tried mightily, if unsuccessfully, to discredit the group's "unsubstantiated" allegations, as an MRC report demonstrated.

The racism toward Mexicans that Trump has stirred up has been swooshing around the basement of the Republican Party for some time. Representative Steve King of Iowa did Trump one better in 2013 when he said undocumented immigrants had “calves the size of cantaloupes because they’re hauling 75 pounds of marijuana across the desert.”

....

Using the X-ray vision of his new glasses, [Gov.] Perry has correctly diagnosed the problem, and forecast the outcome. But that toxic mix has been just the tonic for his party for years, including Perry’s suggestion that Texas might have to secede. President Obama was barely into his first months in office when Representative Joe Wilson of South Carolina shouted “You lie!” at him in a joint session of Congress. For hurling that insult, Wilson was widely praised in conservative media circles.

Egan has either forgotten or is ignoring the time in February 2005, when Democrats mocked President George W. Bush during a State of the Union address for a Social Security claim, without any similar hand-wringing from the Times about insulting a sitting president with derisive heckling.

Trump also stoked the humiliating lie about President Obama’s citizenship. He began that crusade, he claimed, because so many Republicans still believe it, and have encouraged him to keep it alive.

More bias by omission: Egan neglected to mention that the "birther" hoax was started by supporters of Hillary Clinton during the 2008 primary.

At least Egan has found one Republican he likes: Moderate Obamacare supporter (or as Egan calls him, "sensible conservative") Gov. John Kasich of Ohio, who just might save the Republican Party from the "monster" it has created.

CyberAlerts
2016 Presidential
New York Times
Timothy Egan
Donald Trump
John Kerry

Source URL: http://www.newsbusters.org/blogs/nb/clay-waters/2015/07/26/nyts-egan-finds-trump-inevitable-monster-racist-vet-smearing-birther