NewsBusters
Published on NewsBusters (http://www.newsbusters.org)

Home > NYT's Bruni Files Desperate, Petty Accusations of Sexism Against Rand Paul, GOP

NYT's Bruni Files Desperate, Petty Accusations of Sexism Against Rand Paul, GOP

By Clay Waters | June 18, 2015 | 9:47 PM EDT
Share it Tweet it
0
shares

Frank Bruni went petty to accuse the Republican candidates of backwards sexism in his Wednesday's New York Times column, "The G.O.P.'s Blinkered Contenders."

Bruni, who previously served as a White House correspondent for the Times, used a single word from an off-the-cuff comment by Sen. Rand Paul, a libertarian-leaning Republican presidential contender, to bizarrely condemn the entire party for sexism – "a medieval metaphor" that "revealed an antiquated mind-set." The word? "wife."

The Republican Party keeps announcing its new modernity, declaring its new inclusiveness, swearing that it has changed and then showing that it hasn’t.

Witness Rand Paul, who is supposed to be one of its fresher, unconventional faces.

He spoke at a dinner here on Saturday, in a blazer and khakis instead of a suit, and once again presented himself as a Republican unusually in touch with the sensibilities of younger voters, especially concerned about the welfare of minorities and uniquely positioned to expand the party’s reach.

It was a refreshing pitch -- until a medieval metaphor revealed an antiquated mind-set.

He was describing people’s need to feel that their personal information in cyberspace is as safe from indiscriminate government snooping as the documents in their dwellings have long been, and he mentioned the adage that 'a man's house is his castle.'

Then he updated it: 'Now we would say a man or a wife's home is their castle.'

A man or a wife's?

Aiming for a less sexist, more sensitive vocabulary, he came up with a more sexist, less sensitive one, casting women as auxiliaries of men.

This was no way to rebrand the party, no way to retire any image of it as a preserve for old white guys.

If using a traditional family word in a traditional phrase for a family home is the worst example of sexism that Bruni can glean from the Republican field, then the GOP will win the womans' vote in a rout. Speaking of sensitive phrasing, Bruni referred to both Sarah Palin and Sen. Ted Cruz as "wacko birds" in a 2013 column.

Bruni certainly didn't apply to Rand the tolerant standards the news media applies to Vice President Joe Biden, whose numerous "off-the-cuff" word gaffes are either ignored or laughed off. Instead Bruni milked Rand's informal word choice for far more than it was worth.

But it was emblematic. For all the party’s self-congratulation about a field of official and unofficial presidential candidates who depart from the fusty norm, the truth is that they don’t depart nearly enough....he came across as more backward-acting than forward-looking during that strange sequence of interviews with female journalists a few months ago, when he admonished and interrupted them.

Like a good liberal would, Bruni doomed the Republicans for their stands on gay marriage, global warming, and illegal immigration, as well as their personal religious beliefs and stubborn refusal to just get with the program and become social liberals already.

And his Republican rivals, beneath their playlists and campaign choreography, aren’t so impressively in touch with the times either.

....

And none of the leading contenders has a pitch that strongly reflects a recent Gallup poll’s finding that more Americans label themselves socially liberal than at any point in the last 16 years. These Americans finally match the percentage of those who call themselves socially conservative.

Where’s the Republican presidential contender for them?

Interestingly, Bruni left off one of the hottest buttons of all -- abortion -- perhaps because Gallup polling data shows (as of 2010 anyway) that "Americans Aged 18 to 29 Trending More Anti-Abortion."

Bruni concluded that "Hillary Clinton...sought to counteract the familiarity of her presence with the novelty of her promise. She pictured a woman in the Oval Office." Meanwhile, "...Paul pictured a woman in a castle -- and all he saw was a wife.."

CyberAlerts
2016 Presidential
Double Standards
Feminism
New York Times
Frank Bruni
Rand Paul

Source URL: http://www.newsbusters.org/blogs/clay-waters/2015/06/18/nyts-bruni-files-desperate-petty-accusations-sexism-against-rand-paul