NewsBusters
Published on NewsBusters (http://www.newsbusters.org)

Home > NY Times Suggests Death Penalty for Boston Terrorist a 'Blot' on City's Shining Reputation

NY Times Suggests Death Penalty for Boston Terrorist a 'Blot' on City's Shining Reputation

By Clay Waters | May 16, 2015 | 10:01 PM EDT
Share it Tweet it
0
shares

The front of Sunday's New York Times will evidently be blessed with "Death Penalty Leaves Boston Unsure of Itself." The paper found the death sentence handed down to convicted Boston Marathon terrorist bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev a "blot" on Boston's compassionate liberal reputation, which has rendered the finish line "a place of ambivalence," with no end of self-righteous Bostonian handwringing on the matter.

Seelye had pushed in previous stories the activism of leftist nun Sister Helen Prejean, who lent what Seelye termed "moral authority" toward the defense's plea for leniency for Tsarnaev, who killed four people and wounded hundreds more with pressure cooker bombs set by he and brother Tamerlan at the Boston Marathon finish line. On Sunday Seelye (with reporters Abby Goodnough and Jess Bidgood) did not hide her distaste for Tsarnaev's death sentence.

The Times quoted hordes of previously undiscovered law-and-order liberals who perversely claim to embrace punitive Supermax prisons (which provide long sentences, solitary confinement and other punitive measures reserved for the very worst inmates) as an alternative to the death penalty.

The finish line of the Boston Marathon is a landmark here, a blue and yellow slash across Boylston Street that for more than a century has represented pride and achievement for those who stagger across it in one of the great races of the running world.

....

But since a federal jury on Friday sentenced the convicted bomber to death, the finish line suddenly seems to be a place of ambivalence. Fresh flowers are accumulating. A sense of sorrow lingers in the air. Sightseers who come to snap a photo feel a little self-conscious. Residents train their gaze on the line, and the conversations turn to death -- and disappointment.

“I was shocked,” said Scott Larson, 47, a records manager who works near the finish line. “The death penalty -- for Boston.”

U.S. Attorney Carmen Ortiz said that Dzhokhar Tsarnaev would pay for his crimes with his life. Mr. Tsarnaev was sentenced to death for his role in the 2013 Boston Marathon bombings.

The Times gave death penalty opponents ample room to opine, with reactions rather less about justice for the victims of terror than self-righteousness:

To many, the death sentence almost feels like a blot on the city’s collective consciousness. To the amazement of people elsewhere, Bostonians overwhelmingly opposed condemning the bomber, Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, to death. The most recent poll, conducted last month for The Boston Globe, found that just 15 percent of city residents wanted him executed. Statewide, 19 percent did. By contrast, 60 percent of Americans wanted Mr. Tsarnaev to get the death penalty, according to a CBS News poll last month.

No one here felt sympathy for him. Rather, many thought life in prison would be a fate worse than death, especially for someone as young as Mr. Tsarnaev, who is 21. Others feared that putting him to death would make him a martyr. Still others, interviewed around the city Friday night and Saturday, reflected the region’s historical aversion to the death penalty.

....

Like many others, he could not square the death sentence with the sense of Massachusetts exceptionalism that has pervaded Boston since 1630, when the Puritan John Winthrop said this spot in the New World would be “as a city upon a hill -- the eyes of all people are upon us.”

Mr. Maher, walking in South Boston on the waterfront, lamented that Massachusetts seemed to be losing its lofty goals and a piece of its unique identity. “The Chinese put a lot of people to death, and we put a lot of people to death, and almost nobody else in the world does,” he said. “It’s kind of a brutal thing. And for this to happen in Massachusetts ...” His voice trailed off.

....

The jury was “death qualified” -- each juror had to be open to the death penalty; anyone who opposed it could not serve. In that sense, the federal jury did not reflect the general population of the region. Massachusetts abolished the death penalty for state crimes in 1984 and has not carried out an execution since 1947.

Still, some people outside the courtroom did favor death for Mr. Tsarnaev.

Peggy Fahey, a lifelong Bostonian who was sipping coffee on a park bench in South Boston early Saturday, said she believed that Mr. Tsarnaev had been treated too gently since his arrest and that death was what he irrefutably deserved.

....

But many more seemed to share the view of Priscilla Winter, 56, an elementary school teacher from Dorchester who was strolling along the South Boston waterfront. To her, the verdict felt morally wrong.

....

Ms. Winter’s walking companion, Liam Larkin, 57, said he lived around the corner from the Richards. Like them, he said, he wanted the closure that a life sentence would have brought.

“I think the best way of punishing him would be to send him to the Supermax,” said Mr. Larkin, who works removing lead from old buildings.

The Times uncovered more allegedly tough on crime liberals:

“I think that was too simple, to put him to death,” said Ms. Pouncy, 39, who works in accounts receivable at a hospital. “I think he needs to suffer some. Death is too easy. Once it’s over, it’s over.”

Mr. Pouncy, 47, agreed, adding that he wondered how much solace the death penalty could provide for survivors. “The families who lost people are still going to be numb. Maybe they’ll feel like a little bit of justice has been done, but all in all, it’s not going to bring their loved ones back.”

Do liberals truly think "it's not going to bring their loved ones back" is an idea that's never occurred to the family members of murder victims?

 
Crime
Capital Punishment
War on Terrorism
New York Times
Massachusetts
Dzhokhav Tsarnaev
Katharine Q. Seeyle
Abby Goodnough

Source URL: http://www.newsbusters.org/blogs/clay-waters/2015/05/16/ny-times-suggests-death-penalty-boston-terrorist-blot-citys-shining