NewsBusters
Published on NewsBusters (http://www.newsbusters.org)

Home > NYT Reporter Turned Columnist Cheers Traffic-Blocking Left-Wing Protest in Manhattan

NYT Reporter Turned Columnist Cheers Traffic-Blocking Left-Wing Protest in Manhattan

By Clay Waters | April 20, 2015 | 9:21 PM EDT
Share it Tweet it
0
shares

Rachel Swarns, who for years fawned over Barack and Michelle Obama for the New York Times, now writes a column for the paper's Metro section, "This Working Life." On Monday she penned an open letter to liberal actor/activist Adam Baldwin in defense of a left-wing group which tied up traffic in mid-town Manhattan in the name of a $15-an-hour "living wage," in "An Actor Backs Living-Wage Protesters (as Long as They Don’t Snarl Traffic)."

It started when actor Adam Baldwin, an angry and often vulgar leftist, complained on Twitter about being stuck in traffic.

Swarns, who works for a newspaper that covered ad nauseum Republican Gov. Chris Christie's "Bridgegate" scandal, took a different view of traffic inconvenience done in the name of a liberal cause.

As richly mockable as Baldwin is, one can't help but sympathize when he's pitted against snark-mistress former reporter Swarns, who used the freedom of her column to be even more explicitly ideological:

Dear Alec Baldwin,

I threw everything aside to write to you as soon as I heard about your troubles. You know, last week, when you stumbled across thousands of fast-food employees, home health care aides and other low-wage workers who were demonstrating in Midtown Manhattan.

You were on your way somewhere, right? Driving or biking, maybe, when you encountered those protesters calling for a $15 minimum wage? They converged on Columbus Circle as they marched to Times Square, joining tens of thousands of people around the country calling for better pay. And in that moment, as you were stuck in the traffic snarled by that rally, something touched you. Something inspired you to speak out.

Your instinct, of course, was to let loose on Twitter:

“Life in NY is hard enough as is. The goal is to not make it more so. How does clogging rush hour traffic from 59th St to 42 do any good?”

....

Mr. Baldwin, I’ve always been a big fan of yours -- loved “30 Rock” -- and I’ve written quite a bit about workers who are still struggling during this post-recession recovery. So I must confess that I worried that your Twitter message sounded just a teensy bit insensitive to the protesters who, after all, just want to feed their families, pay rent and try to stay afloat. Or maybe you agree with some business owners who say that a $15 minimum wage is unsustainable?

“Oh, I support their cause. The timing of their event wasn’t what good NYers would do....”

What a relief! That message really eased my mind. I’m sure that it made Julia Andino, a single mother who works at McDonald’s, feel better, too. Maybe you saw her? She was protesting because she earns $8.75 an hour -- minimum wage in New York State -- and struggles to pay the rent for the single room that she shares with her 3-year-old son.

....

They were all out on Wednesday evening, marching, chanting and calling for change that might improve their lives.

Swarns had the gall to compare this "social movement" to Selma:

Just think back to the recent coverage of the 50th anniversary of the 1965 “Bloody Sunday” march across the Edmund Pettus Bridge in Selma, Ala.

I watched some of that on television and not a single correspondent that I saw posed the pointed question: What kinds of traffic disruptions did those civil rights activists cause when they tried to cross that bridge?

(Ambulances/other emergencies presumably got no sympathy from Swarns either.)

The lecture wasn't over:

It’s just that sometimes, Mr. Baldwin, people do take stands to try to bring about change for the better. And sometimes their protests disrupt our day-to-day routines. Sometimes, they’re even intended to disrupt our day-to-day routines, to open our eyes, to bring attention to causes that might otherwise be ignored.

Swarns praised the privileged Michelle Obama as just a humble mom in a May 2009 article: "Mrs. Obama has long been known as frank and down to earth. Now, as first lady, she is bringing some of that sensibility into the Executive Mansion, particularly when it comes to laying out the day-to-day thrills and challenges of her domestic life." In July 2009 she raised the hagiography a notch: "After several months of focusing on her family, her garden and inspiring young people, Mrs. Obama is stepping into more wonkish terrain."

Barack Obama himself wasn't neglected. In November 2008 Swarns wrote of the president-elect: "In a country long divided, Mr. Obama had a singular appeal: he is biracial and Ivy League educated; a stirring speaker who shoots hoops and quotes the theologian Reinhold Niebuhr; a politician who grooves to the rapper Jay-Z and loves the lyricism of the cellist Yo-Yo Ma; a man of remarkable control and startling boldness...."

Wages & Prices
Liberals & Democrats
Poverty
New York Times
New York
Rachel Swarns
Alec Baldwin
Chris Christie

Source URL: http://www.newsbusters.org/blogs/clay-waters/2015/04/20/nyt-reporter-turned-columnist-cheers-traffic-blocking-left-wing-protest