Founder of Mine Company Slams Media for Misleading Reporting

By Terry Trippany | August 7, 2007 - 16:00 ET

Bob Murray is the founder and President of Murray Energy Corporation, the company that owns and operates the Utah mine that collapsed after an earthquake struck the area on August 6th. Apparently he has been under a lot of pressure from the mainstream media and various interest groups to accept blame for what he calls a natural disaster. But Mr. Murray is not taking the pressure sitting down. This morning he held a press conference to cast away any doubts as to the cause of the collapse, clear up any misconceptions about the mine's safety record and put the American people on notice that they should not depend on the Associated Press for any truths. He also took a swipe at Fox News and Congress for recent global warming legislation; a little something for all. (video at Webloggin)

I particularly cite Mr. Seth Borenstein of the associated press for particularly bad reporting and as of this morning the Fox News Network on what has occurred here. Rather than utilize the truthful statements that you have heard here, the associated press and Mr. Borenstein chose to use statements from Mrs. McAteer, Oppegard, Odell and Roberts, who were totally false and have nothing to do with or have any understanding of what's happened here. And this morning Fox News network was at it also. I hope you report that and I will cite to you in every one of these interviews all false reporting that we hear. But I would certainly not depend on the Associated Press and Mr. Borenstein for any truths if I were an American citizen.

The statements by Mr. Murray are in response to an article that Borenstein wrote this morning that looked past any facts in cause of the Utah mine collapse and concentrated instead on the type of mining being done. Borenstein then solicits the comments of a private attorney who used to work in the mining industry. The angle, as expected, is one where the mines forgo the safety of the workers to get the last bit of coal for "pure profit", finally alluding to the conclusion that the pay off is worth the risk because a collapse would wipe away the evidence of rules violations.

WASHINGTON - The method of mining used at the Utah mine that collapsed Monday, trapping six miners, has a history of being disproportionately deadly, according to federal safety studies.

[~snip]

It is "the most dangerous type of mining there is," said Tony Oppegard, a former top federal and Kentucky mine-safety official who is now a private attorney in Lexington, Ky., representing miners.

According to the American Society of Safety Engineers, retreat mining requires precise planning and sequencing to ensure roof stability while the pillars supporting the roof are removed.

The reason the practice is used is that it pays off: The last bit of coal taken from pillars is pure profit, Oppegard said. Plus, if someone violates rules during pillar removal and there is a collapse, the evidence of rule violations is gone, he said.

There is no doubt in my mind that an agenda is being driven in Borenstein's report. Why else would he concentrate on the type of mining being done instead of getting geological information that would substantiate or disprove the claims of the mining company? The last sentence about the evidence of rule violations "being gone" is simply ridiculous. A perfect drive by for a perfectly silly report that leads the reader to believe that a greedy corporation is violating safety rules to make a quick buck.

Mr. Murray did not stop at the press however. He also took a swipe at global warming legislation working its way through congress.

"We produce a product that is essential to the standard of living of every American because our coal produces 52% of the energy in America today, and it is the lowest cost energy, costing 1/3rd to 1/4th the cost of energy from natural gas, nuclear and renewable energy resources. And without coal to manufacture electricity our products will not compete in the global marketplace against foreign countries because our manufacturers depend on coal, low cost electricity and people on fixed incomes will not be able to pay their electric bills. Everyone one of those global warming bills that have been introduced into congress today eliminates the coal industry and will increase your electric rates, four to five fold."

Mr. Murray has worked in the mining industry all his life, he knows his facts and he came to the fight ready to take on all willing. Today the press met its match.

This article is crossposted at Webloggin.

 

Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

If mining has the

If mining has the reputation as being very, very dangerous, why is it such a shock when there are these terrible accidents? That being said, my heart goes out to the miners and their families.

The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.

- Arabian Proverb

3 mile island.

during the three mile island mess there was a coal mine cave in about 30 miles down the road.

they lost about 20 miners, it got one mention in the drive by media.

what was that about not much use having a free press if its false? 

C

I remember back then

During the hearings (congress, I forget whether House or Senate) on the radiation leak, they picked up more background radiation  in the (congress) building than was reported downwind from Three Mile Island.

  Ignorance is bliss. It's easier to repeat a mindless slogan than to do some actual research.

WOW!!!

Good on this guy!

And FNC needs a kick in the @ss. Lately they have sipped on the kool-aid the rest of the MSM takes on non-stop I.V.

Amen, Mr. Murray.

And G-d bless and help those six miners and their families.

It's Fox News' style of

It's Fox News' style of breathless tabloid reporting. I can't stand it. 

The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.

- Arabian Proverb

They need to stop with

They need to stop with reporting on the pop-tart flops.  I'm really sick of it. 

You mean...the MSM distorts the truth and lies?

I wonder if he figured this out before now...or did this incident bring it to light for him? Hell, we've known they're fulla crap for years now.

And you know they can't stop with the celebrity coverage. I'm sorry to say it , but the vast majority of folks out there love it when a "Star" falls or rises. (The average I.Q is what...85 or so?) Bread and circuses my friends...bread and circuses. Happy Trails...

FoxNews

 I remember, during Katrina, Shepherd Smith out there crying the blues and repeating false stories he'd heard and repeating the MSM mantra that the Feds were at fault.  That night, at least, he could have been a reporter for CBS, NBC, or any other network.  My greatest wish, at that time, would have been for Fox to get it right and the others to keep repeating the hogwash, it didn't happen, until much later. 

In this case, Fox wants to lead the parade.  Too bad.

Never argue with an idiot.  They'll drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.

Ditto the Virginia Tech coverage

by Shepard Smith...he was as bad as any msm reporter with his questions on "how do you feel about this/that" - a horrible tragedy had just occurred and the last thing ANYONE should be asked is "how do you feel about it"

Fox needs to turn it down a notch or two and simply report the news.  The same with the recent bridge collapse in Minnesota.  It appears they want to be the televised Enquirer...but what they should know is that the viewer wants JUST THE NEWS, FOLKS, JUST THE NEWS!  And forget the special music they dream up to draw attention to the latest catastrophe...JUST THE NEWS, FOLKS, JUST THE NEWS!

And I am a loyal Fox News channel viewer.

How do you feel?

Every time I see a reporter interview some bereaved person after some tragedy I want to throw up. How do you THINK someone feels after tragedy strikes? 

  Ignorance is bliss. It's easier to repeat a mindless slogan than to do some actual research.

No Earthquake!

This guy is just ranting, no one wants to ban coal -- everyone wants
cleaner coal energy, and it's available for a few bucks more.
Fox News' Megan Kelly and her expert concluded there probably was no
earthquake, because there were no aftershocks. The collapsing mine set
off the Richter scale
It would be the first ever earthquake with not one aftershock..

NW...There was an

NW...

There was an aftershock according to Mr. Murray and his info given to him by experts a 2.0...you may want to listen to all of this...from Breitbart (correction to upper/or lower post of mine about name of link) 

Night, It won't matter if there was a quake or not......

Ahh, that's okay, because whether or not this was caused by an earthquake, or two stars colliding millions of lightyears from our solar system, you guys will still blame this on George W. Bush.

You people won't be happy untill we are paying $20.00 a gallon for third-rate kerosene.

Help Fred defeat everybody.

you guys will still blame

you guys will still blame this on George W. Bush

Or George Bush's Global Warming ... It's a toss up. When I see RFK, Jr.'s mug on TV I'll have confirmation.

LOL Drill... I am quite

LOL Drill...

I am quite sure I posted that too on OT yesterday about blaming this on Bush/Cheney.

It never ends with these leftist nutcases....never.

Dave R,

Dave R,

Only a nut job like yourself would conclude that I blame this accident on the President. Why would say something so dumb?

We will be paying $20 for a gallon for gas if the Enron like
manipulation continues. The WH and Congress needs to ban futures
trading of oil/gas, for speculators who never take delivery. It's like
the Mafia shaking down every gas station for $1 a gallon; they pass it
on to us. There is no shortage, we'd be waiting in line.

NW... WE need to drill

NW...

WE need to drill here and be independent.

As BD said long ago...

Drill Often!....Drill Everywhere!

drill anwr

drill anwr ... the moose and bears will love us for it.

BT, I'd drill my back yard

BT,

I'd drill my back yard next to the pool, if I thought oil was there -- strap on a diving platform.

We need to stop CLOSING refineries. They closed 200 in the last 20 years.

Hear anything on that huge discovery BP found in the Gulf, almost two years ago?
I don't think they got a drop from it yet.

Of course I have heard

Of course I have heard about it NW...

Believe me I have posted links about all you are talking about along with others here in the last almost two years.

Refineries and all...including other places here in the US.

The leftists and RINO's like McCain for example have stopped any progress for thirty plus years.

The msm is complicit with their dumbing down America and their won dumbness with all of this all for the leftist agenda.

This will be at the expense of us all...one way or the other...

It already is.

This is one major part of who I am going to be voting for... besides the SC and the safety of our country including illegal immigration...adn Victory against the terrorists world-wide, not just the enemy within, that goes without saying for me. 

Funny you mention "I'd

Funny you mention "I'd drill my back yard next to the pool" because a drilling company just paid me $900 for a 3 year lease on my land in the heart of Arlington.  Thank God for the Barnett Shale. They do drill where they think there is petroleum.

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.

Night,

Because I firmly believe that many on the left in this country are being disengenuous (at best) when they claim to lament high enegy prices.

I think many of them want higher prices, for the simple fact that at some point, they will have a negative impact on the economy.

If I am wrong, then why do the same people who are constantly complaining about high gas prices are the very same people who refuse to vote to allow us to do what is required (including building more refineries) to increase the supply?

I'll tell you why. It is because they know an increase in supply will lower the price at the pump, and that is the last thing they want to see happen.

Help Fred defeat everybody.

"everyone wants cleaner

"everyone wants cleaner coal energy, and it's available for a few bucks more"

Oh really?? A few bucks more huh? Where DOOOO you get your information? As far as I a concerned you enviro nuts can shove coal and give me and my grandkids nukes!!!!!

"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...

The Jury is still out on the quake

I live in western PA and beleive me there is an out-an-out campaign from the enviromental-cases to curtail the production of coal. Reasons: Cause acid rain, C02 in the atmosphere etc. Legislation has been presented to stop liquid coal converstion plants from being built.

As far as your earthquake asserstion the juy is still out

http://earthquake.usgs.gov/eqcenter/eqinthenews/2007/uu00007535/#news

 

 

 

Thank you so much Mr.

Thank you so much Mr. Trippany...

I was just getting ready to put a link in from Breitt TV with a lot of this information.

I posted on the open thread yesterday afternoon about the msm going after Mr. Murray, who stood toe to toe with Boxer and others on an Energy/GW hearing that I also posted about with a link to C-Span months back.

This man is the salt of the earth and says it likes it it...period.

I was absolutely furious yesterday afternoon into late evening with FOX just like I was with FOX when it came to SEGO, the UMW Union has an agenda just like he says, he creamed FOX, which is about past time as far as I am concerned...

A special man who has worked in the mines, been trapped in the mines, held friends as they have died in the mines...

We finally have a real person sticking his middle finger up to the msm...someone who has lived, breathed, mortgaged everything he has into a business and made the American Dream come true by risk, hard work, and his belief in the good Lord.

Amen to you Mr. Murray...we need more fine men like you to speak out, just like you did to Boxer, just like you did to the false breathless reporting from the msm who do not know where they speak from sitting behind an anchor desk barely ever got out of the city in their whole lives and projecting their own or others agenda.

I also have been in, worked with men/women who make their living in mines in my lifetime, they are a family, just like all industries that either the Unions or the enviro's or both hand in hand throw in the trial lawyers and the leftist party that all have an agenda.

Fox News sickened me last night beyond description.

Like I said yesterday, it still holds today...my heart and prayers go to the families and the men trapped...May God Speed...and also to you Mr. Bob Murray...you are a new hero of mine, but then again you already were months ago.

I wanted to stand up and cheer.

I heard this on Rush's show earlier today.

I wanted to stand up and cheer.

Help Fred defeat everybody.

Dave... Howdy ...if you

Dave...

Howdy ...if you get the time later this evening you really should listen to all of the Press conference...it was one in a million.

I was listening to it on Fox when it came on and they INTERRUPTED him as he was talking even before he got down to the criticism/scrutiny of their reporting...I was furious, so I turned it to CNN  and listened to all of the rest uninterrupted.

(Needless to say the other networks were happy with the well deserved criticism, but they were smart and did not gloat...not yet anyway...for once that is)...also because they all have the same agenda...and it is everything Mr. Bob Murray is against...

LOL!

Btw...I heard Rush and his reporting on it...which made me smile naturally, but there was so much more in the Press Conference. 

bt,

Afternoon to ya, and glad to see the fire that we all know GWB started has left you alone. After all, it ain't Texas that's on fire. :-^)

...so I turned it to CNN and listened to all of the rest uninterrupted.

You know, as bad as I hate to say it, if I were CNN, I'd be running that press conference a lot, too.

Fox is getting sloppy, and I think they deserve a smack once in a while.

Help Fred defeat everybody.

More than once in awhile

More than once in awhile anymore as far as I am concerned Dave...

I can barely tolerate the station anymore than the others...and that is saying a lot for a gal who called everyone (including a lot of my relatives in Ca. who did not have it yet or had heard of it) when the station first started and refused to get a little dish until the included Fox on it out here where you had to shovel a path at times to get to the dish in the middle of winter to brush off at four or so in the morning with a flash light in mouth while doing so.

I have about had it with them anymore.

But then again...that is just me.

bt,

I'm at the point where I don't even watch TV news anymore, as it has all become so mind-numbingly stupid. Even the local news here in Atlanta isn't really worth watching.

About the only time I turn it on is if something major happens.

Otherwise, its the radio or the internet for me.

Help Fred defeat everybody.

CRIPES!

I hear ya, Dave! My local news stations here in NE Ohio are part of the democrat machine.  Same here with me in getting my news/info.  I've divorced Big Brother.

You're in Atlanta ... My doctor sister is in Fayetteville.

drill,

LOL-That's a nice area, as it has yet to be contaminated with libtard "city slickers."

Help Fred defeat everybody.

Dave R, You need to be

Dave R,

You need to be watching more Bill O'Reilly, he'll tell you what to thunk.

Night,

I can tolerate the first five minutes of BOR.

Then its the Food Network for me.

Help Fred defeat everybody.

I wasn't glued to the TV

I wasn't glued to the TV coverage of this story, but I gotta ask:

Now what exactly did Fox News do? If they reported all  sides of a story, including the "negative" that was attributed to someone else, wasn't it living up to their motto, "fair and balanced"?

 

Start each day with a smile, then get it over with. - W.C. Fields

Their absolute accusatory

Their absolute accusatory nature against the mines before the men are even rescued has been outrageous as far as I am concerned, they do it all the time, the guilty before innocent is getting old no matter the subject/person's.

Never an apology form them or any in the media when this happens.....think back to the recent rape accusations with Nifong, the station jumped on that like stink on shite...never apologized.

I expected better from Fox, they are just wanting to be number one Accusatory arseholes anymore....the rest fall in line.

Body count at 190..........

 190 murders in Baltimore this year....you may be safer in a Mine than in Downtown after dark.  Mining is dangerous, driving on an Interstate is dangerous, living in America is dangerous. 

You take your chances crossing Bridges in Minnesota, life is Dangerous, and Congress cannot pass a law to fix it....  

What good is a Free Press, if it is a False Press ?   David Foote  GoE

I listened to some of it,

I listened to some of it, but got tired of him droning on and on about his lifes story.

chess... Droning on and

chess...

Droning on and on?....

He was fighting the msm ....he had every right to tell his experiences, the msm knows not of what they talk about most times when it comes to others or their jobs....of course with the exception of their high and mighty ones.

I have nothing but extreme admiration for the man. 

Bravo Mr Murray!!! Its

Bravo Mr Murray!!!

Its time to open up a can of whoopa$$ on these clowns.

Bring in the clowns...oh I hate that song...

VT... Exactly... It was

VT...

Exactly...

It was Hannity that made me furious last night with his pompous know it all crap, and he did it again tonight only he tried to rectify what and why he said what he said.

I was furious once again.

Btw...I have noticed Fox when reporting on Bob Murray's criticism of them, they never have said he stated FOX....they say the media...which I find hysterically hypocritically maddening...

They have become what I detest more and more as the days go by.

Glad to see someone that's

Glad to see someone that's not going to take this crap. Seems like every tragedy that occurs the dem beaurocracy looks for the easiest person,group,whatever, to blame and a quick solution. It's just so sad that people like them think it's all a half hour sitcom and when the show is over the problem is gone. Wake the @^%# up!

I hope to hear more from Bob Murray.

"I hired you to get some track laid, not jump around like a bunch a kansas city faggots" Slim Pickens

Bob Murray for president!

Bob Murray, president of Murray Energy Corp., is my man! FINALLY, someone who takes on the miserable media by using their knowledge to counter propaganda! Keep loud and proud, Bob, and all the best to you and the miners.

 

j17... I Second that

j17...

I Second that Motion!

With Zest!

He is the Give em Hell Zell........

Too dang bad and sad that the conservatives in our party don't get a hint by great everyday men like him.! Especially when it comes to the reality of life and where our everyday energy comes from.

Like I said in OT yesterday ...the long knives were going to be out for him anyway after I saw him take on Boxer and others in Congress...

It was the most refreshing thing I have ever seen at any hearing I have ever watched in my almost 15 or so years of watching them all.

Btw...On top of all of this they are still having aftershocks and are having to suspend some of the rescue for now....the media, especially Fox hated to report that and made that questionable in itself.

Pathetic.

I "third" it!

Mr. Murray is a symbol for all of us who would like to have a chance to say the things he did!

Have you heard?

How many of you know that three of the six men trapped are citizens of Mexico? I wish all of them, and their families, a successful outcome.

Today there was a collapse

Today there was a collapse of the rescue tunnel from of all things an earthquake and they called it sesmic activity.  Isn't that what the owner said was the cause?

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.

And now the reporting on

And now the reporting on this mine collapse looks even more inept & biased that it did before.

 

Fred Thompson and Ann Coulter walk into a bar. The bar is instantly destroyed because that much awesome cannot be contained in one building.