ABC's Claire Shipman Bizarrely Spins Rahm Emanuel as 'Centrist'

Photo of Scott Whitlock.
  • Bookmark and Share

"Good Morning America" reporter Claire Shipman continued a time honored media bias tradition on Friday when she mislabeled Congressman Rahm Emanuel, Barack Obama's newly selected chief of staff, as "centrist." Emanuel, who was elected to Congress in 2002, has a lifetime American Conservative Union score of 13.

In 2006, his rank was only four. In contrast, the House member's average from the liberal group Americans for Democratic Action is a very high 96. And yet, Shipman erroneously asserted, "More than anything, the 48-year-old Illinois representative is a pragmatic, centrist politician who likes to get things done. Clearly, Obama wants the same thing." So, can Americans expect Obama to be the same type of "centrist" that Emanuel has been?

Shipman is not the first journalist to try and spin the aggressive Illinois congressman as a moderate. On Wednesday's "American Morning," CNN special correspondent Frank Sesno described Emanuel as someone who is seen to be "on the center to center-right."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

Interestingly, the rest of Shipman's report actually featured more negative descriptions of the soon to be chief of staff. Co-host Robin Roberts commented on his "abrasive style." She observed, "He once jokingly told the Chicago Tribune, quote, 'I wake up some mornings hating me, too.'" Shipman labeled him "hard-charging" and "in-your-face." She added, "Emanuel was so abrasive early on in the Clinton White House, Hillary Clinton wanted him fired."

In what could be seen as a conflict of interest, former top Democratic aide-turned journalist George Stephanopoulos appeared in a follow up segment to talk about Emanuel, a colleague of his in the Clinton White House. He allowed that Emanuel could indeed be "abrasive at times." But he then defended his friend against charges by Republicans that Emanuel violates Obama's pledge to change Washington:

GEORGE STEPHANOPOULOS: But, on the other hand, he's also built bridges with lots of Republicans, like John McCain's best friend, Senator Lindsey Graham. He had a working group in the House with Republican Congressman Ray LaHood where they would have a series of bipartisan dinners. So, there's two sides to that story.

Of course, there was no mention of the past association of the two.

A transcript of the November 7 Shipman segment, which aired at 7:05am, follows:

ROBIN ROBERTS: Now, to more on Obama's new chief of staff, Rahm Emanuel. He's a Democrat with a reputation for ruffling some feathers in Washington. His abrasive style has drawn some criticism, even from himself. He once jokingly told the Chicago Tribune, quote, "I wake up some mornings hating me, too." Our senior national correspondent Claire Shipman has the story from Washington. Good morning, Claire.

CLAIRE SHIPMAN: Good morning, Robin. That is classic Rahm Emanuel. And, yes, some Republicans are already grumbling that his temperament isn't exactly what Barack Obama promised when he talked about a more conciliatory style here. But the two men have been friends for years. Obama has told people privately he thinks Rahm's rough edges have been softened. And he can operate on Capitol Hill like nobody else. Hard-charging. In-your-face.

CONGRESSMAN RAHM EMANUEL: They have seen jobs be shredded.

SHIPMAN: Take no prisoners. The cliches describing Rahm Emanuel's style are stacking up fast. They may be on target, but they miss the point. More than anything, the 48-year-old Illinois representative is a pragmatic, centrist politician who likes to get things done. Clearly, Obama wants the same thing.

JOE LOCKHART (Fmr. Clinton White House press secretary): He knows the White House. He knows how the government, the executive branch works. And he knows how the hill works. Rahm is a very strong personality. But, I think everybody, you know, whether you like him or not, people respect him, because he gets the job done.

SHIPMAN: Emanuel was so abrasive early on in the Clinton White House, Hillary Clinton wanted him fired. But he later earned her respect as he helped to push up her husband's popularity and pushed through measures like welfare reform. He made millions later as an investment banker and then later ran for Congress in the same Chicago district where his immigrant doctor father used to make house calls. The Emanuel children were all expected to follow Benjamin's example of making good. The family joke is that only Ezekiel, a renowned oncologist, has gone into a respectable profession. But if art imitating life is at all a measure of success, Ari is a smooth-talking, A-list Hollywood agent. And the inspiration for Ari Gold in the hit TV show, "Entourage."

["Entourage" clip]

SHIPMAN: And Rahm's tenacious, impassioned, sometimes abrasive style, is said to have given birth to the Josh Lyman character on "West Wing."

["West Wing" clip]

SHIPMAN: Emanuel is a devout Jew and heavily focused on family. The toughest part of the decision, uprooting his family back to Washington.

EMANUEL: I've been in the White House. I used to joke in the White House that- on Fridays I would say, "It's two more work days to Monday."

SHIPMAN: Like all good characters, Emanuel has quirks to spare. And if you look closely, you'll see he's missing the middle finger of his right hand. He sliced it off as a teen, working at a fast food restaurant. But instead of going to the hospital, he went swimming. The wound became so infected, he almost died. He is also a former ballet dancer, talented enough have been offered a scholarship to the Joffrey Ballet. He had some high praise for his many talents last night from one former White House resident.

SENATOR HILLARY CLINTON: Well, I think that President-elect Obama made an excellent choice. Rahm Emanuel understands both ends of Pennsylvania Avenue. He understands the private sector, where he was successful for a number of years. He gets things done.

SHIPMAN: And you can imagine, Diane, the primaries were tough for him. He had to remain very neutral between Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama.

—Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

The essence of journalism

I'll never forget a conversation I once had with one of our company salesmen. When I argued that the package he was trying to sell a client was unfair, and would cause the client to pay for services that he didn't want, I'll never forget the salesman's answer.

"I don't want you to think of it that way."

Well, yeah, of course you don't. And to be clear, it wasn't that I had misunderstood his argument. He agreed with me. He just didn't want me to think of it that way, When he said it, the clarity of the spin really struck me. I mean, he was so upfront about it.

So when I see these reports from spinners, in the media as well as the campaign, I hear them as echoes of that spin. Rahm Emanuel is a dedicated partisan. (There's nothing wrong with that, in my opinion.) But I reject the spin that says that he's a centrist or that he's sympathetic to conservatives. These media types don't actually offer any arguments. They just don't want us to think of Rahm Emanuel, or Obama, in that way.

And frankly, this is a Tessio moment. Any media hack who defends or deflects attitudes on Obama's behalf, especially trying to get us to think of things in their way, is a traitor to "objective" news reporting. Like Tessio in The Godfather, whoever offers you "security" with your opponent, the offer alone reveals the traitor. Shipman's report gives her away.

Funny you should mention 'the Godfather',

Funny you should mention 'the Godfather', here's the kind man Obama put in charge of the White House staff, from blog.foreignpolicy.com:

1. Mailing a Dead Fish

... one pollster who notoriously ticked off
Rahmbo received a 2 1/2 foot decomposing fish in the mail -- ripe, stinky, and to the point.

2. Fundraising the Bugsy Siegel Way

... His sales pitch was simple enough: He'd tell contributors he found their offers so low it was embarrassing and then hang up on them. Mortified, the donors were shamed into calling back and giving more.

...

4. Threatening Tony Blair

... just before the then British prime minister appeared with President Clinton during the Monica Lewinsky scandal: "This is important. Don't ---- it up."

5. Knifing the Dinner Table

... the dinner the night
after Bill Clinton was elected in 1992... an overwrought and clearly exhausted Emanuel began ranting at a long list of Clinton "enemies." As he shouted each name, he stabbed the table with his steak knife: "Nat Landow! Dead! Cliff Jackson! Dead!"
Apparently, others joined in.

 

This is more lies

I am a centralist and these lying SOBS can go FOAD in a hard way!Next they will be saying Pol Pot was a humanitarian.It is sick how these pabs just keep pushing their propaganda.

Liar

Claire Shipman is an idolizing fool and a liar; just like the great majority of the MSM are liars. They are not quite foolish enough to search their own minds and find total belief in their fantasies.

This makes them not so much fools as they are liars AND the Father of ALL lies is their Father. Does anyone know of what I speak? Hint: Pharisees

You aint kidding

It is so pathetic the way they lie and get away with it.Journalistic ethics is a joke.I dont know how they can look in the mirror.

How to manual

Page 3.

How to discredit yourself in only 3 seconds.  it reads,

1.  Go on national television with your name on the screen.

2.  Claim proudly:   "Emanual is a Centrist..."

3.  Pause until audience stops laughing at you.

Claire....seriously?  A Centrist??  the only thing Emanual is in the center of are his delusions of grandeur.

[that said, if i were as far left as i am right, I'd be psyched with Rahm as COS and that Obama didnt try to pick a centrist or someone who would 'reach across the aisle' to 'play nice' with all]

the latest quote...

Obama:  "Vicious, partisan hack?  That's not the Rahm Emmanuel I knew."

 Interesting side note:  I work in Beirut, Lebanon.  Was watching Al Jazeera English channel today.  They were interviewing a Palestinian about Bush's final Middle East peace initiative.  In the course of the conversation, the man being interviewed made some interesting observations.  He claimed that Israel was being given a blank check by the U.S. to carry out its current operations.  He didn't expect this to change much, as much of the Congress that holds power is under the influence of the Jewish lobby in the States.  He didn't really hold out much hope for Obama either, given that - as he put it - Obama just appointed Rahm Emmanuel as his Chief of Staff, a man (again, as he put it) who has defended Israel's right to exist and who is himself an Israeli.

Guess the Middle East isn't getting quite the change that it hoped for, huh? 

They just keep trying to

They just keep trying to repackage the same old manure in a shiny new package and sell  it as "Naturally Produced Organic Soil Enricher and Plant Nutrient"  but it's still  manure.

MB

You arent kidding.Same lies just another day.

(Sigh) Still another Stupid Media Trick

Ms. Shipman and Mr. Sesno just performed yet another timeless Stupid Media Trick: calling flaming liberals "centrist" to hide the fact that they are flaming liberals.  This is yet another example of: "How can we fool 'em today?" 

The saddest thing of all is that millions of suckers fall for this garbage, hook, line and sinker!

Claire, Claire, Claire

Let me help you out here, you've got it wrong.

.... the 48-year-old Illinois representative is a hard-left, money-grubbing, Machiavellian rottwielier unconcerned with blood or tears.

 

 The sad thing is I've

 The sad thing is I've heard a few Conservative talk shows call him a centrist too. Even if he is, it doesn't matter. He works for Obama, Obama doesn't work for him, and Obama is no centrist. 

 

Josh SN: "Obama is one of the smartest lawyers of his generation."

Emmanuel the Enforcer

JOE LOCKHART (Fmr. Clinton White House press secretary): . . . But, I think everybody, you know, whether you like him or not, people respect him, because he gets the job done.

 SENATOR HILLARY CLINTON: . . . He gets things done.

 Of course they respect him; they don't want to get on his bad side since they are now outside the White House.   They are politely describing the Democratic Party's knee-capper, and they ought to know, because they got to watch him operate up close for them  inside the Clinton Administration. 

Emanuel was an outstanding choice by Obama for his Chief of Staff.  Obama knows that Bill Clinton's honeymoon was squandered by undisciplined staff meetings that wasted hours and failed to reached decisions.  Clinton's Gays-in-the-military move was nearly political suicide and unnecessary.  Clinton had to fire his childhood buddy McClarty and bring in Leon Panetta to install order and discipline.

Emanuel will start off that way out of the box; weak players will be fired.  He will compensate for Obama's executive inexperience.  With dozens, maybe even hundreds of special interest representatives clamoring to get the new President's ear and commitment, scary-guy Emanuel will readily dismiss all but the ones deemed important to the agenda, and keep Obama on track.  This includes do-nothing windbags like Pelosi and Reid, who will receive marching orders from Emanuel and like it.

 That having been said,  Emanuel is a smart, partisan liberal who will use those Republicans who yield totally to his will, and attack those who resist.  Don't look for much bipartisanship, unless it's cleverly calculated to give ground in something unimportant to Obama in order to create the appearance of bipartisanship.

 

 

 

Wright is

positioned in the center right? ROFLMAO

The whole UCC Church is way to the left. Rev. Wright is far to the left of the main theology of the church. I know this from the inside of a local UCC church. Thank God that each individual church is democratically governed! The promotion of this sort of tripe in the church has driven members and churches away.