ABC is Second Network to Highlight 106-Year-Old Nun for Obama

Photo of Scott Whitlock.
  • Bookmark and Share

Jim Sciutto, ABC, For the second time in three days, a major network program has showcased the story of a 106-year-old nun in Rome who is voting for Senator Barack Obama. On Wednesday's "Good Morning America," reporter Jim Sciutto highlighted Sister Cecilia Gaudette, an elderly woman who has caught "election fever" for the Democrat. The journalist featured Gaudette gushing, "I think he's the man, really. I think so."

Although the story was touted on the October 12 edition of the "CBS Evening News," Sciutto acted as though there was some mystery as to who the women might vote for. "We didn't ask her to reveal who she chose, but she couldn't help telling us," he announced. (Would journalists trek all the way to Rome just to file a report on a nun voting for a conservative candidate, such as John McCain?) And just as with the CBS piece, there was no mention of any possible conflict over a Catholic nun supporting the pro-abortion Obama.

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

After being prompted by Sciutto as to what qualities the next president needs, the elderly Gaudette replied, "He should be like a father and love his people. And do the best, of course." (The nun is an American citizen and will be voting through the overseas ballot program.)

Sciutto closed the segment by repeating Gaudette's vow to participate in the 2012 election. In a possibly telling remark, co-host Robin Roberts replied, "I'm not voting against her."

A transcript of the October 15 segment, which aired at 7:18am, follows:

7:01am tease  

ROBIN ROBERTS: And we're also going to introduce you to America's oldest voter. She's 106. She's a nun. She's living in Rome. The last person she voted for, well, she wanted to be like Ike. Let's just put it that way. We'll tell you why she felt it was so important to cast the ballot once again and her advice for the next president .

DIANE SAWYER: That's right. Love her and love how she had to apply to register, too.

7:18am

ROBERTS: But now, we want to introduce you to America's oldest voter. She's 106. She's a nun living in Rome and the last time she cast a ballot she liked Ike back in 1952. That's the last time she voted. But something about this presidential election has her voting again. And as Sister Cecilia explains to our senior foreign correspondent Jim Sciutto, she does not envy the man who wins in November.

JIM SCIUTTO: This year, election fever has made it all the way to the Convent of Jesus and Mary in Rome. And for no one more so than Mother Cecilia Gaudette. At a sprightly 106-years-old, she is the oldest overseas voter, possibly the oldest American voting anywhere this year. She reads the paper every day and watches the evening news religiously. Politics, though, is a new hobby. The last time she voted was 1952 for Dwight Eisenhower. Do you think this election is important?

CECILIA GAUDETTE: I think it's very important. I pity the poor man who will be president.

SCIUTTO: She asked a younger nun, Mother Mary is only 78 years old, to help her get her overseas ballot. The trouble is, on the U.S. elections website, the birth dates only go back to 1905, three years after Mother Cecilia was born. But they got her a ballot in the end and a chance to speak her mind.

MOTHER MARY: And she was happy to know that she could vote.

GAUDETTE: [Looking at ballot.] Sarah Palin?

SCIUTTO: Having lived through 18 presidents, Mother Cecilia has advice for number 19.

GAUDETTE: He should be like a father and love his people. And do the best, of course.

SCIUTTO: We didn't ask her to reveal who she chose, but she couldn't help telling us.

GAUDETTE: Obama.

SCIUTTO: Yeah.

GAUDETTE: I think he's the man, really. I think so.

SCIUTTO: Her last word? Not likely. She assured us she's planning to vote in 2012, as well. For "Good Morning America," Jim Sciutto, ABC News, Rome.

ROBERTS: 2012. I'm not voting against her.

DIANE SAWYER: Not even.

ROBERTS: I'm telling you what. She is something else.

—Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

The media loves you

Christopher Buckley decided to endorse Obama, and Chris Matthews rushed him to the camera. "Tell us why you endorse Obama," Matthews cooed. Now they go to Rome to find a 106-year old nun. "Tell us why you endorse Obama," they coo,

Neither one mattered until they endorsed Obama. They were used. Exploited. Let everyone know that if they want some TV facetime, endorse Obama. 

My Mother-in-Law is a hard

My Mother-in-Law is a hard core Catholic who would have been a nun herself if she hadn't been prom queen back in the day, but she's a total Obamite and I can't figure it out.

The guy is for infanticide, for God's sake!  Yet this extremely devout Catholic looks at Obama as if he were St. Jude or someone.

Inexplicably sad.

Mathew 24:24.  "For

Mathew 24:24. 
"For false Christs and false prophets will arise and will show great signs and wonders, so as to mislead, if possible, even the elect.

Nuke em til they glow then shoot em in the dark.

Good news!

Oh c'mon, Mother Cecilia does not have to wait four years to vote in the 2012 election - she can do it right now, right, Acorn?

 

Nun for Obama

by definition, is no longer Catholic.  Is she senile?

Scott - Wow

Scott - How long has she been in Italy? It's difficult for non-Italian citizens to remain in Italy for an extended period? Does she have dual citizenship?  Perhaps the church makes for an expection to the rule. 

You know last week or so, ABC - well JakeTapper on his blog - also covered the shocking story of Shelly Mandell, the LA Chapter president of NOW who introduced and expressed strong sister feminist support of Gov. Palin at a local campaign rally. Of course, more than 3/4 of Tappers blog column was made up of a scathing rebuttal by the state president of NOW. How dare a lowly local Chapter president do such a thing.

I searched the LA Times here a moment ago to see if they had printed a story on Ms. Mandell's support of Palin - and big surprise, the newspaper which only a few days ago; see Dave Pierre's post, LAT Trumpets 'Longtime Republicans' For Obama, could find no sense in passing the story of a life long Democrat activist being "for Palin." Better if the voters are not troubled by such; goodness, they could be tempted to think for themselves. (;~> gary

This is all quite simple- as

This is all quite simple- as a Catholic you cannot vote for someone who publicly endorses abortion (or, even worse, in Obama's case- infanticide).  If you do, you have excommunicated yourself, and are no longer a Catholic.  This goes for any Catholic- lay or clergy.  Commandment #5: Thou shalt not kill.  What's so hard to understand about that?

Apparently she had tuned

Apparently she had tuned into Kieth Olbermann by accident.

"Forget change, I want improvement!"

106 years old?

I hope they let her vote early.

Maybe she thinks the election of...

"The One" will be the apparent Triumph of Evil and bring on the Second Coming,maybe, just trying to cut her some slack.

 

 

 

 

Anyone who has ever heard Santayana's famous quote about History repeating itself is condemned to repeat it.

...

"SCIUTTO: We didn't ask her to reveal who she chose, but she couldn't help telling us."

Gee, I'll bet you and your bosses at ABC were really surprised.