ABC's Cuomo Fears New Yorker's 'Supposed Satire' Could Spread

Photo of Scott Whitlock.
  • Bookmark and Share

On Monday's "Good Morning America," the show's co-hosts appeared quite bothered by the "supposed satire" of a New Yorker magazine cover that features a cartoon Michelle Obama as a black militant and Barack Obama in Muslim garb with a picture of Osama bin Laden in the background. And although the issue is obviously meant as a parody and a representation of the liberal view that conservatives are attacking the Illinois senator's patriotism, Cuomo fretted, "Is that the way people see him?"

An ABC graphic for the second segment on the topic, a discussion with Democratic strategist James Carville, featured this warning: "Cover Controversy: Does New Yorker Cover Go Too Far?" In a tease for the subject, co-host Robin Roberts asked, "Did the New Yorker go too far with this week's cover?" Cuomo, making clear his belief that, whatever the satirical intent, the cover wasn't appreciated, opined, "The New Yorker is not even on the stands yet, but this supposed satire has a lot of people talking."

Story Continues Below Ad ↓

GMA correspondent Jake Tapper filed a report on the topic and noted that the Obama camp has labeled the cover "tasteless and offensive." Cuomo agreed and again worried about its impact: "Jake, tasteless and offensive, yeah. But what about also effective? I mean, do you think we're going to start seeing this everywhere? This is the last thing the campaign needed right now, right?"

Cuomo then interviewed Carville on the subject. The longtime aide and friend to the Clintons actually dismissed the New Yorker cover as not that big a deal. (He defended the "really great magazine" and snidely observed, "This is not the Drudge Report. Please.") Cuomo wouldn't let go, however. After Carville brought up the satire defense, the ABC host retorted, "But, I mean, what is there to this point, exactly?" Citing a just released Newsweek poll finding the election between Obama and Republican John McCain tightening, he worried, "Is that the way people see him?

A transcript of the Jake Tapper segment and a partial transcript of the James Carville segment, follow:

7am tease

ROBIN ROBERTS: Cover controversy. Did the New Yorker go too far with this week's cover? The Obama camp fires back.

7:02am

CHRIS CUOMO: And we were looking at the cover a little bit. Let's put that magazine cover back up there. The New Yorker is not even on the stands yet, but this supposed satire has a lot of people talking.

ROBERTS: It does and we'll hear more about that instant fall out coming up.

7:07am

CHRIS CUOMO: Let's get to politics. Let's get to the latest on the race to '08. There's a surprising new poll out. Newsweek has Barack Obama leading John McCain by just three points, a statistical dead heat, really. That's down from 15 points of a lead last month. So, now, the selection of running mate could mean that much more. ABC's senior political correspondent Jake Tapper has all the reporting for us from Washington this morning. Morning, Jake.

JAKE TAPPER: Good morning, Chris. Well, sometime in the next few weeks, Senator Barack Obama will announce his vice presidential pick and shortly thereafter, in all likelihood, Senator John McCain will do the same. But, until then, political junkies are studying every comment, all the body language, every last nuance to try to figure out who the nominees will be. It's like a game of vice presidential "Clue." Family value conservatives were concerned that Republican Florida Governor Charlie Crist would not be a suitable VP pick because he's been a bachelor for decades. Then this month, Crist got engaged. So is it a clue? Crist in Florida with an engagement ring? Minneapolis media have written that Governor Tim Pawlenty's chances of being picked were hurt by his mullet or hockey hair. Suddenly, a new distinguished hair cut. So, is it Pawlenty in Minnesota with a hair cut? 1996 Republican VP nominee Jack Kemp offers this advice.

JACK KEMP (1996 Republican VP nominee): You cannot campaign for it. I think that's the most important thing. Any of you guys out there thinking of campaigning, you can't campaign for it.

JAKE TAPPER: Tell that to Mitt Romney who has shown an amazing willingness to take to the airwaves to praise former foe John McCain.

MITT ROMNEY: He's a person of great capability who has been tested and proven and someone who I respect enormously.

TAPPER: Another clue, Romney on cable with some cheerleading. On the Democratic side, a clue in the Los Angeles Times. Hillary Clinton in New York with an Obama phone call. Clinton fund raiser Jill Iscol was phoned by Obama last week.

JILL ISCOL (Hillary Clinton supporter): He said that he admired Hillary Clinton. He respected her enormously, how could he not consider her for vice president? And that she certainly was on his list.

TAPPER: Then there's the news over the weekend. Republican Nebraska Senator Chuck Hagel, an opponent of the war in Iraq who has not endorsed McCain, will accompany Obama on the upcoming trip to Iraq. So is a clue Hagel in Iraq on a fact-finding trip? Those are, of course, just a few of the possibilities. Neither the Obama nor McCain campaigns are talking about the matter. But one thing that the Obama campaign is talking about this morning is that new cover of the New Yorker magazine which features a cartoon of the Obamas in the Oval Office. She is dressed as a black militant. He is dressed in Muslim garb. There's a picture of Osama bin Laden above the fireplace where an American flag is burning. The magazine says it's just a parody of conspiracy theorists' take on the Obamas. But the Obama campaign says the cartoon is tasteless and offensive.

CUOMO: Jake, tasteless and offensive, yeah. But what about also effective? I mean, do you think we're going to start seeing this everywhere? This is the last thing the campaign needed right now, right?

TAPPER: I agree with that 100 percent, Chris. In fact, Chris, this morning I went online. That image is already, the magazine cover, is already on the website of people who hate the Obamas and they are using this against the Obama family.

CUOMO: All right, Jake. Appreciate it this morning. Thank you. Let's get some more perspective here. I think you may have heard laughing from this man, Democratic strategist James Carville is here, author of the book "40 More Years." You're laughing, but is there a little bit of crying going on in the Obama camp over that picture?

ABC GRAPHIC: Cover Controversy: Does New Yorker Cover Go Too Far?

JAMES CARVILLE: I was laughing because it was tasteless and offensive and I was the next guest. You know, look. Does the New Yorker have a history of being a really great magazine and a responsible magazine? Of course it does. Does it have a history of using satire? Of course it does. This is not the Drudge Report. Please. And I think that David Remnick, who is the editor there, is a pretty smart guy. They've got pretty smart people, I think they knew what they were doing. I understand where the Obama campaign is coming from. I don't know I wouldn't feel the same way. But, given the context of everything, I think that we all know what the New Yorker was doing. They were trying to use satire in making a point at that I'm sure the Obama people would like made at some point.

CUOMO: But, I mean, what is there to this point, exactly? I mean, you're looking at the poll. Right, we had the numbers up there before for the Newsweek poll. The numbers are compressing. He's up 15. Now, it's a statistical dead heat. Is that the way people see him?

CARVILLE: You know, Chris, you can't look at one poll. And that's the danger. And I think if you look across either Pollster.com or RealClearPolitics.com, they'll show the race is about seven points right now, six or seven points. And that seems about right to me. You're always going to have some variations and fluctuations But I'm not at all convinced that there's any kind of severe tightening going on. Newsweek polls show this. Other polls show different things. It's still a fairly close race here. And it's still a race I would say that Senator Obama is the favorite, but there's certainly a way for McCain to do this.

—Scott Whitlock is a news analyst for the Media Research Center.


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

The Obama will be not

The Obama will be not mocked.

McNotObama '08

the BH '0' camp has a new lesson to learn:

if you know how to throw them, you better learn how to catch em.

There will be...

...riots in the streets of all Muslim countries once they see this.

Another Obama "Don't" for this campaign

  • Don't talk about my liberalism!

  • Don't talk about my Chicago friends!

  • Don't talk about my pastor!

  • Don't talk to me about clinging to guns and religion!

  • Don't talk about my wife!

  • Don't talk about my policies!

  • Don't talk about my lack of experience!

  • Don't talk about my flip-flops!


And now, Don't draw pictures of me!

___________________________________ 

If you can read this, thank a teacher. If it is in English, thank a Soldier. - My barber

More of Osama Bama's hypocrisy!

Thisnthat,

Isn't it interesting that Osama Bama was willing to let himself be photographed in a muslim outfit - complete with turban -  but when New Yorker puts a cartoon on their cover depicting him in said garb, it now becomes offensive to him?

And he wonders why his lead over McCain has evaporated.

"How can you be in two places at once when you're not anywhere at all?" - Firesign Theatre

 

You mean this photo of his

You mean this photo of his Feb 2006 trip to Kenya? Looks just like the New Yorker cartoon drawing, IMO. What's Obama's beef? He said he didn't have any comment, I believe.

___________________________________ 

If you can read this, thank a teacher. If it is in English, thank a Soldier. - My barber

Ears. You forgot his

Ears. You forgot his ears.

McNotObama '08

Sounds like another (false)

Sounds like another (false) prophet, doesn' it?!

I'll give you three guesses, and it's not Jesus or Moses.

 

RightWired.

"How do you tell a Communist? Well, it's someone who reads Marx and Lenin. And how do you tell an anti-Communist? It's someone who understands Marx and Lenin." - Ronald Reaga

affirmative

"Did the New Yorker go too far with this week's cover?"

The answer is yes, yes it did --  by the cartoonist's own admission, the cartoon was meant as a sarcastic portrayal of "conservatives" as xenophobic wackos.  As usual, the left-leaning MSM goes way too far with anti-conservative propaganda.

I concur.  It is doubtful

I concur.  It is doubtful any Conservative publication would do anything of the sort, and if it did, it would surely not have been on the front cover.

Liberals are given license to be offensive.

I find it amazing that liberals are given much leeway to be very offensive with their artistic license and freedoms of expression. Examples are: art that mocks Christianity, homosexual street fairs that include public sex, nudity and displays of S&M and foul, violent and misogynistic lyrics in rap music, among many others which don't come to mind right now. If you can think of more examples, please help me.

This New Yorker cartoon is just another example of how liberals are allowed to be offensive, but they hold conservatives to a much stricter standard. If a conservative publication printed this cartoon they would have been condemned as racist, xenophobes and hate mongers. The left wing media and supposed civil rights leaders would not rest until someone was fired if this cartoon was published by a conservative..  

This only works when

This only works when conservatives let themselves be cowed by liberal criticism and attacks. Too many "conservatives" (okay, the few)in politics and the media act like they believe that somewhere, deep down, the liberals are right about them.

McNotObama '08

New Yorker Magazine

Isn't it amazing that there are derogatory cartoons

in every local and city newspaper about George

Bush, almost daily, and you never hear a comment

from Pres. Bush, nor do readers usually comment

or condemn them.  Poor Obamamanma can't take

the heat.    What's he gonna do when a terrorist

or a foreign dictator say bad things about him?

 

Is he gonna faint, or cry?   Needs to get some

thicker skin and fortitude.   He's definitely not

presidential material.

Do not be deceived, Obama is

Do not be deceived, Obama is not mocked; for whenever man mocks him, that we will also defend him. (Gaglations 6:7) MSM version of the Holy DNC Scriptures.

This is the Word of

This is the Word of Obama.  All praise Obama.

 

McNotObama '08

It's completely a Democrat thing

It amazes me that this "satire" from Democrats about Democrats is all conducted without any participation by the Republicans in any way. The Republicans don't even exist in this discussion. They didn't create the cover. Neither McCain nor any GOP group is promoting the stereotypes supposed satirized by this picture. It's all Democrat urine in a completely Democrat pissing match.

Maybe Las Vegas will take bets on which media hack will be first to blame conservatives. I just don't know how they're going to do it, but you know that they're trying to convince themselves (even as I write this) that it simply must be part of the right-wing conspiracy.

"It's all Democrat urine in

"It's all Democrat urine in a completely Democrat pissing match."

I'm adding that to my "Analogies to Use Before I Die" list, if you don't mind.

 

------------------------------------------------------------

"It could be the answer to our age-old, philosophical question, 'Why are we here?' PLASTIC!"

Analogies

Be my guest. Now I can cross it off my list. LOL!

Hold the Media ACCOUNTABLE. ENOUGH

I am so damn tired of the double standards.

When in the hell the media cover the hit piece done by Rolling Stone, mocking McCain's torture?

Someone, anyone at MRC, NB, Rush, Malkin, Coulter, Hannity, Savage, SOMEONE needs to make them address this on air and explain themselves as to why it's ok to insult McCain but not Obama, and WHY do they not cover this stuff.

This election is going to be won by the MSM again if we dont' start raising a stink. NOW.

RightWired.

"How do you tell a Communist? Well, it's someone who reads Marx and Lenin. And how do you tell an anti-Communist? It's someone who understands Marx and Lenin." - Ronald Reaga

"When in the hell the media

"When in the hell the media cover the hit piece done by Rolling Stone, mocking McCain's torture?"

Good point.

 

------------------------------------------------------------

"It could be the answer to our age-old, philosophical question, 'Why are we here?' PLASTIC!"

Cuomo was clearly holding back the tears...

Satire may spread? So satire is now an infectious disease.

 

"Don't hate me because I am beautiful..."

One of the tests for anything like this is:  would they be outraged if the parody or satire were about a conservative or Republican?  NO! Of course not.  How much outrage by ANY liberal or Democrat was there when a movie was made with the assassination of George Bush as the topic?....crickets chirping. 

Mocking the Boy Scouts, Christians, conservatives, Middle America, Republicans and Jews is okay as long as you claim to be a Dem or Liberal or gay or the like.  Everyone else is then fair game.  Make a factual and truthful comment as a Christian or conservative, etc, and you are run out of town on a rail.  Make a few comments - comments! in an e-mail and you are evicted from the House (Foley).  If you take a $100,000 bribe and $90K is found in your freezer......you are STILL in office years later (Jefferson).

Scott, thank you...

...for documenting ABC's "supposed reporting."

--Mike

www.thebrattonreport.com

 

New Yorker absolutely went to far !

"Did the New Yorker go too far with this week's cover?"

You betcha - they need to stick to the script:

    

It won't spread

The New Yorker took one for the team. Jesse's remarks are becoming a distant memory.

Soon this will be relegated to a "news story" on the Conservative smear campaign where they show brief glimpses of past Liberal spawned cr@p that has "somehow" been transformed into Republican ownership.

And the sheeple will murmer, "MMMM, yeah, that's right. Racist smear mongering Republicans."

"All generalizations are false, including this one.” Mark Twain

Ignatz, a most insightful

Ignatz, a most insightful commentary. Sadly, quite likely prescient as well.

Nobody will remember where it originated in 3 months and the MSM sure ain't going to remind them.

Tomato, to-MA-to

You say Satire, i say hitting the nail on the head.

All BS aside, this is just to keep the media from having to address the 'real' Obama. That's the last thing the left wants. They will keep running crap like this until they have enough people believing that everything negative they hear is false.

What makes Satire work?

When there's truth in it.   The left knows this.  They know what he is.  And if he wins the White House and sets us on the road to destruction, leftists can say, 'You KNEW what he was.  We told you!'

Definitly NOT satire...

  • Definitly NOT satire (Irony, sarcasm, or caustic wit used to attack or expose folly, vice, or stupidity)
  • Maybe hyperbole (A figure of speech in which exaggeration is used for emphasis or effect)
  • Most likely Freudian slip (A verbal mistake that is thought to reveal an unconscious belief, thought, or emotion.

Yahoo American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language

→ When Barry met Larry

Heaven forbid the spead of satire.

Remember New Yorker's "Brokeback Mountain" Bush/Cheney cover?  (not that there's anything wrong with it).  I dare say there was quite a bit more talk about a brokeback liason between Barack Obama and Larry Sinclair than Bush/Cheney.

I see the Obama camp's reaction as something of a satire in itself.

He dresses seductively in Islamic garb in Kenya, and we're not supposed to call him a tart?

LYDSEXICS UNTIE

CA

"...not supposed to call him a tart?"

LOL. Thanks for the laugh today. I didn't see THAT one coming.

Worried little warts

Worried little warts all...now aren't they...

I have had nothing but fun...

Man what is really pathetic is the majority of the msm needs to take a breath and step back, listen to the slug Carville and let feet touch ground to some kind of earth.

Oh well...not gonna' happen, so I will keep snickering...

Btw...what hypocrisy with all of this... selective outrage.

Nothing like convenience.

"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh

I will start it yes

I am on the way to the computer store to buy the trans fer paper and a shirt the pic is on file so I can transfer it to a shirt . Thanks New Yorker for the great visual.