Almost two years ago, NewsBusters wondered when media would begin reporting Enron's ties to higher oil and gas prices.
Recently, we've gotten our answer: when it could be blamed on the Republican presidential nominee.
Such was certainly the case Wednesday evening when Obama advocate Keith Olbermann did a segment on "Countdown" pointing fingers at John McCain for having not done more to repeal the so-called "Enron Loophole" created by the enactment of the Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000.
Though predictable, Olbermann conveniently ignored how the first version of this bill passed in the House with almost unanimous bipartisan support, cleared final approval in the Senate by a voice vote without any objection, and was signed into law by Bill Clinton who had also been a strong advocate (video embedded upper-right, use scrollbars to center):
OLBERMANN: John McCain is renowned for saying he does not know much about the economy and for parading around those advisers of his who he says do know something about the economy. our third story tonight, A COUNTDOWN special report on the price of gas, and how McCain`s chief economic adviser, among others, helped create and defend pivotal legislation that unleashed speculators to run up gas prices. It is, in essence, a legalized form of insider trading, deregulation that lets speculators overwhelm trading in oil futures, those complicated contracts that let commercial users of oil hedger their bets about future price and supply fluctuations by agreeing to prices and delivery dates ahead of time.
Since this legislation passed, gasoline prices have more than doubled and commodity traders have made tens of millions of dollars, devastating thousands of small companies that deal in oil, and creating the risk of a speculative bubble popping.
How does McCain fit in? The road connecting him to four dollar gas begins with Enron.
(BEGIN VIDEOTAPE)
OLBERMANN (voice-over): Soon after Enron`s birth as a power supplier in the 1980s, CEO Ken Lay decided head could make more money betting on electricity futures, especially if government regulators didn`t stop him from cornering the market and gaming the system. Under the first President Bush, an obscure agency called the Commodities Future Trading Commission obliged Ken Lay. The CFTC chairwoman, Wendy Gramm, left Enron alone.
When Bill Clinton beat Bush, it took only one week before Enron asked Gramm to lock in her hands-off position as official CFTC policy. Gramm started the process. The CFTC approved it after she left on Clinton`s inauguration day. Five weeks later, she took a part-time post on Enron`s board of directors and wound up earning more than 900,000 dollars over the next decade. Clinton never undid Gramm`s changes.
Fast forward to the year 2000 and Bush v. Gore. In the chaos of constitutional crisis, Enron got a law passed containing what is now known as the Enron loophole. Where Gramm deregulated individual trades, the Enron loophole deregulated entire markets, online markets. [...]
Since 2006, John McCain`s top economic adviser has been former Texas Senator Phil Gramm, husband of the former CFTC head who then joined Enron. McCain chaired Gramm`s 1996 presidential race, with Ken Lay as regional chairman. It was Gramm who passed the Enron loophole, partially written by Enron itself, with no hearings, with no debate.
It was Gramm who stopped Democrats from closing the Enron loophole, and it was Gramm who became vice chairman at the Swiss financial firm UBS in 2002, less than a year after UBS bought the shattered remains of Enron`s energy trading arm.
This would be quite a scoop for Olbermann if there was any truth to it. After all, the Senate's version of CFMA, co-sponsored by Gramm, was never debated or voted on.
By contrast, it was the House that got CFMA through the legislative process by initially passing H.R. 4541 with almost unanimous support. In fact, the final vote cast on October 19, 2000, was 377-4. 180 Democrats, including current Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Cali.), voted in favor of this bill.
Of course, as Gramm was in the Senate, he couldn't vote on this House bill. I guess such facts eluded the oh-so-intelligent Olbermann.
Months later, this bill became part of a larger, end of the year consolidated appropriations act, H.R. 4577, which passed the House by a vote of 292 to 60. Only nine Democrats voted against it. The bill was later approved with a voice vote by the Senate -- without objection -- and signed into law by President Clinton on December 21.
As such, blaming this loophole on then Sen. Gramm, and tying it to McCain, defies any logic or intellectual honesty on the part of Olbermann and his MSNBC producers.
Color me unsurprised.
As an aside, and as not only stated in my August 2006 NewsBusters piece about this issue but also in my June 9 National Review Online article, I strongly believe this Enron loophole is adding to the speculative bubble in energy prices, and needs to be immediately repealed. However, as CFMA enjoyed overwhelming bipartisan support when passed in 2000, I find it utterly disgraceful for anyone -- especially someone that considers himself to be a journalist -- to point fingers of blame either at one Party or one person.
Sadly, as one of the most biased members of the news media today, this is indeed Olbermann's modus operandi.
The good folks at General Electric should be so proud.
—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Another fair and balanced
June 20, 2008 - 09:42 ET by NewsbusterbrownAnother fair and balanced report by Keithie-boy.
“There are no easy answers' but there are simple answers. We must have the courage to do what we know is morally right.” - Ronald Reagan (1964 Republican Convention)
Imagine
June 20, 2008 - 09:56 ET by cvgbuckeyeCould you just imagine the reactions of Chet Huntley and David Brinkley if they were able to come back from the grave and see the kind of goofy, unintelligent simpleton that NBC has lowered themselves to putting on the airwaves?
They certainly leaned a little left also but at a minimum they were talented and jounalists and not goofy looking and speaking.
And its more than just Simpleton Olbermann, although he is likely the worst. Its also Matthews, Abrams and all the rest and that whole team of left wing simpletons that msnbc now has on at 6:00 PM.
Do these people really think that anyone with half a brain believes all the lies that they never stop telling? They don't believe it themselves. This has got to be the most stupid bunch of people ever gathered together in one building in the history of civilization.
Krazy Kieth gets his news
June 20, 2008 - 10:59 ET by kgKrazy Kieth gets his news from Daily KOS (BS) so what else can you expect.
"Forget change, I want improvement!"
Why, it's almost as if a third party or 2
June 20, 2008 - 09:54 ET by sarcasmoCould use the bipartisan scandal as an(other) issue. Not that they'd ever get a chance, due to "unbiased" FECal BS like this...
JMR
The tax & spend drug war looks racist in the real world.
Clinton's economic house of
June 20, 2008 - 10:08 ET by mattmClinton's economic house of cards began to fall in late 1999 and 2000 and by the time the spit hit the fan, BJ was out of town and W was left to clean up the mess resulting from 8 years of the Animal House administration - and take the blame for it.
Now, dipwads like Ubermanic have to find a new Republican to blame for Clinton's failure and corruption, so of course it's McCain. If Romney had been the nominee, he'd be to blame.
Facts don't matter to liberals.
Wow, Olberidiot is switching gears early...
June 20, 2008 - 10:29 ET by c5thenHe should have blamed this on Bush as he does with everything else. Now he has apparently moved on and everything will now be McCain's fault. It's nice to see that he reads the memos from the DNC with his morning coffee.
The day that "politician" became a career choice is the day we started losing the Republic. Let's get it back! Alan Keyes '08.
How long is Olbermann going
June 20, 2008 - 10:32 ET by suzycreamcheeseHow long is Olbermann going to be allowed free reign to smear people on his show? I guess he's hoping that the more he can lie about Republicans and McCain before the election, the more voters will swing over to Obama's side. I just can't believe this man has his own show. Why hasn't he been sued yet?
On this matter
June 20, 2008 - 10:55 ET byI don't think Olbermann blamed McCain for this, but rather calls into question how Gramm is is now affiliated with his campaign. The real issue is if Gramm is to blame for the Enron loophole. This post seems to say Gramm is not responsible because he wasn't in the Senate. This seems to be a slight of hand, because he was responsible for this loophole.
Gram was the one who slipped the Commodity Futures Modernization Act into this current bill. I can only assume it was the same one that didn't pass the House Vote, because it was the one co-sponsered with Senator Luger. A congresional aide had said that nobody in either chamber had any knowledge in what was in it.
Gramm even talked up this act in the Senate, as a matter of fact.
So I would put some responsibility (a lot) on Gramm for pushing this through, and which makes it so much worse (unless your Gramm, which makes it great) is that he was able to cash in from companies like Enron.
So, yeah, Olbermann probably overstates when he says Gramm passed the Enron loophole, this post doesn't really do a service to the readers when you imply Gramm had no involvment in this bill passing.
Also, you leave out a whole portion of Olbermann's report and how this Enron Loophole aplies to all energy companies and how their specualtion raises the price of gas and the elimination of this loophole would lower prices. I assume you left this out either because of a spacial issue.
s
June 20, 2008 - 11:45 ET by Noel Sheppards,
Gram [sic] was the one who slipped the Commodity Futures Modernization Act into this current bill.
Could you give my readers a civics lesson as to how Sen. Gramm put CFMA into a House bill and why this mitigates responsibility of the all but four Representatives that voted for it? Please provide links to government websites supporting your position, while avoiding opinion pieces on the subject. ns
s
June 20, 2008 - 13:23 ET byI"m not a Constitutional Scholar, but I am pretty sure Congressmen can add legislation to bills at committe meetings.
And I put a lot o blame on the whole Congress for this fiasco, because that is what it is. But the whole post was about how Phil Gramm was not responsible for this fiasco. That just seems to be untrue.
http://www.motherjones.com/news/feature/2008/07/foreclosure-phil.html
http://www6.lexisnexis.com/publisher/EndUser?Action=UserDisplayFullDocument&orgId=574&topicId=100007428&docId=l:806708304&start=1
http://www.motherjones.com/mojoblog/archives/2008/06/8723_national_review_1.html
S
June 20, 2008 - 13:44 ET by Noel SheppardS,
I asked you to support your claim with actual facts and NOT opinion pieces. Can you oblige or not? ns
Could you give my readers a
June 20, 2008 - 14:50 ET by NewsbusterbrownCould you give my readers a civics lesson as to how Sen. Gramm put CFMA into a House bill and why this mitigates responsibility of the all but four Representatives that voted for it?
He willed it with his mind! He willed it with his mind!
l-)
“There are no easy answers' but there are simple answers. We must have the courage to do what we know is morally right.” - Ronald Reagan (1964 Republican Convention)
Without knowing & without looking...
June 20, 2008 - 14:56 ET by sarcasmoI think I'll venture a wild guess as to who's among that 4...Nah, the flamewars have been enough today, but I suspect my guess is right enough that I'll just thank Noel for the absolution in advance...
JMR
The tax & spend drug war looks racist in the real world.
KOS Blogger
June 20, 2008 - 11:06 ET by Logic over emotionThis jerk writes for the Daily KOS and makes daily comments over there. Nuff said.
The good news is that he's preaching to the choir and has no other viewers.
I thank God for writers like Noel that keep on top of these things even if it seems fruitless - it's not. We need to expose these circus barkers at every turn.
There he goes again
June 20, 2008 - 11:21 ET by tracker1973It's sad that Max (Olbermann) Headroom is considered a news presenter. He's acting more like a 2 year old wearing a cold wet diaper. Just look at his face. Hey wait one moment, maybe he should do a show about the enema monument in the Russian city of Zheleznovodsk , now that would put a smile on Max's face.
It will be interesting to
June 21, 2008 - 01:47 ET by Rush FanIt will be interesting to see if any debates between McCain and Obama are held on NBC/MSNBC. If they are, the moderators won’t consist of Olbermann, Mathews, and Abrams (did I miss anyone?). I can’t believe McCain and his advisors would permit those aforementioned bozos to moderate. Now that Tim Russert is gone, there is no one at that network that I would trust to moderate fairly.
Which political party is invested in our defeat in Iraq?