
Read the following paragraph, and imagine it being written by a member of the mainstream media (emphasis added throughout):
Ramadi is an irritating contradiction of almost everything the world thinks it knows about Iraq -- it is proof that the US military is more successful than the world wants to believe. Ramadi demonstrates that large parts of Iraq -- not just Anbar Province, but also many other rural areas along the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers -- are essentially pacified today. This is news the world doesn't hear: Ramadi, long a hotbed of unrest, a city that once formed the southwestern tip of the notorious "Sunni Triangle," is now telling a different story, a story of Americans who came here as liberators, became hated occupiers and are now the protectors of Iraqi reconstruction.
Shocking, yes? Probably written by The Weekly Standard's Bill Kristol or some other conservative columnist, right?
Well, such is not the case, for this truly amazing article was published by Germany's Der Spiegel Friday, which as Ray Drake pointed out to his readers on Monday, has consistently been a staunch opponent to the Iraq war and George W. Bush.
That's all changed now (grateful h/t Say Anything):
When describing Iraq, the word "peace" is seldom used. Truth be told, the Americans have restored order to many parts of the county.
[...]
In October, 90 "incidents" were reported in Tameem, an area no larger than a few city blocks in Berlin. Twenty of those incidents involved attacks on US troops by gangs of insurgents. Wherever the Americans went they were shot at from apartment buildings, three times with rockets and four times with rocket-propelled grenades. Sixteen remote-controlled bombs exploded along the neighborhood's streets, 14 homemade explosive devices were found and defused, snipers attacked the occupying troops twice and one hidden car bomb was found, ready for use. And so the story continued: throughout November, December, January and February.
Then came the surge:
By March, however, the number of incidents reported in Tameem had dropped to 43, including only four direct attacks with rifles and pistols and one rocket attack. There were no bombings, snipers, rocket-propelled grenades or car bombs. And the leaders of the region's 23 powerful clans were finally meeting with US commanders for "security conferences," while the imams from the city's mosques met with the military's chaplains.
The Iraqis in Ramadi, almost all Sunnis, had been worn down by chronic violence. Many had been victims of kidnappings or blackmail at the hands of mafia-like terrorist groups. They had finally come to the realization that, in the long run, the Americans were less of a threat and offered more hope than the fanatical holy warriors from Iraq and abroad.
Americans were less of a threat and offered more hope than the fanatical holy warriors from Iraq and abroad. Can you imagine any American journalist writing such words? Or these:
Families began sending their sons to join the new Iraqi police force and military and fathers ran for municipal offices. They began cooperating with US military officials, turning in bombers and revealing their weapons caches, all while going about their daily lives, running their businesses, working as contractors, shipping agents and garbage collectors. Teachers returned to their classrooms, doctors began treating patients again and store owners restocked their shelves. Iraqis were now building the barbed wire barriers around the city, constructed to force travelers through checkpoints. Iraqis even manned the checkpoints as the Americans -- the Iraqis' former enemies -- retreated to the background, watching over as the city made a fresh start.
Since June, Ramadi residents have only known the war from televison [sic]. Indeed, US military officials at the Baghdad headquarters of Operation Iraqi Freedom often have trouble believing their eyes when they read the reports coming in from their units in Ramadi these days. Exploded car bombs: zero. Detonated roadside bombs: zero. Rocket fire: zero. Grenade fire: zero. Shots from rifles and pistols: zero. Weapons caches discovered: dozens. Terrorists arrested: many.
Amazing.
The reader is strongly encouraged to take the time to review all eight segments of this astounding report that really should be required reading for all American journalists and politicians who still question whether or not the surge is working.
Bravo, Der Spiegel. Bravo!
—Noel Sheppard is the Associate Editor of NewsBusters. Follow him at Facebook and Twitter.




















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Well done.
August 14, 2007 - 13:38 ET by HelenSThis is so cool. It's not a lot, maybe, but it sure is a satisfying start.
Nicely done, Der Spiegel.
"Cry havoc and let slip the dogs of war" - Shakespeare
It is a lot
August 14, 2007 - 13:56 ET by ThisnThatI disagree, HS -- anytime you get a report with "ZERO" problems, you've made enormous progress. I am going to write my Congressman a letter referencing this article and telling him to bring this up on the floor of Congress.
My son, a Marine in Anbar and who was sent over there as part of the "surge", has been reporting the same thing. Complete and absolute cooporation with the Iraqis, huge, huge progress being made on all aspects of getting life back to normal there.
My son, a
August 14, 2007 - 14:16 ET by BeowulfMy son, a Marine in Anbar and who was sent over there as part of the "surge", has been reporting the same thing. Complete and absolute cooporation with the Iraqis, huge, huge progress being made on all aspects of getting life back to normal there.
First of all TnT, give my best to your son, and thank him for me for the job he is doing. I spent three tours in Sand-Land myself, so I know how much it means to be thanked and supported.
Secondly, this is exactly what I've been saying for some time. If you want to know what's really going on in Iraq, ask the G.I.s who are, or have been, over there. This is something I simply can't understand. So many Americans happily chew on the spoon-fed propaganda from our MSM, yet never once question it. Our congress-critters spout off about how bad everything is, and are allowed to do so despite refuting facts. This propaganda war is the single most deciding factor on the American "opposition" to the war that we all keep hearing about until our ears bleed. It has to stop, and perhaps this is the way to do it. Americans relying on foreign news sources.
The Closed Mind Erects Strong Barriers
Our sources of news and support
August 14, 2007 - 14:27 ET by ThisnThatBW, thanks for your service. And ain't it the truth about how we have to go backdoor for our news these days. It's gotta change, and I think the change is going to come sooner than later, and all these current MSM types and Dims are going to be looking for new employment elsewhere.
I just called my Congressman to give her an earful. She wasn't there, of course, but I demanded a response just to know she got the message. Stupid Dim she is.
TnT, Your "backdoor"
August 14, 2007 - 18:54 ET by BlondeTnT,
Your "backdoor" comment is spot-on.
We're not hearing jack from the MsM about what's happening in Iraq. Which absolutely infuriates me.
I try to stay hooked up with my friends, who occasionally point me to something terribly cogent and relevant (I posted a great article on the forums a few weeks back...."The Surge is Working").
That's why I frequent sites like this....and Blackfive...and track down the stories and links posted.
The dems are going to absolutely lose it when the war in Iraq is well on its way to won.....and it's being won in small, incremental steps. It's up to us, though, to keep pushing the issue.
My new plasma TV got married to new cable services....I've become a Military Channel junkie. And what I see on that station absolutely blows my mind. If I were a (neo-con) Nazi....I'd make sure thier broadcast was piped into every American's morning news.
My real hope is that as we get heavily into the presidential race, the (R) candidates will continue to slap down the liberal idiocy (of the moderators) and make a freaking STATEMENT!!!!!!
Which would go along the lines of...."we're tired of your LOSER mentality....we are winning, so STFU!" And then kick them while they're on the floor reeling, with "what on earth are you jabbering about....political solutions?".
Ditto
August 14, 2007 - 14:25 ET by Dr_LibertyA big ditto to Thisn That. I also know a few guys stationed in Ramadi and the biggest complaint for them now is boredom. They also note local store fronts are actually starting to look like store fronts with people mingling in the stores. This means that supplies for these stores are getting into town, which also indicates that the roads in and out of the province are becoming safer.
<insert witty signature here>
Boredom is good
August 14, 2007 - 14:37 ET by ThisnThatAs a parent, hearing about boredom is good. Don't need the excitement.
TnT-
August 14, 2007 - 18:24 ET by drillanwrJust remind him (and his brethren) to stay sharp.
G-d's blessings ...
Agreed
August 14, 2007 - 22:41 ET by Dr_LibertyI'm doing my part to increase the "excitement" by sending out DVDs, yahtzee pads, cards, hand held computer games, Soduko books and other stuff to our guys in Ramadi.
<insert witty signature here>
Peace and oil
August 14, 2007 - 13:53 ET by KC MulvilleIt has always been the case that if these people stop fighting, they're sitting on a fortune in oil. They don't have to like each other, or attend each other's church. All they have to do is not kill each other, and they'll be rich beyond their dreams.
The solution is not in Baghdad. That's why I'm not concerned that there hasn't been more progress made by the Maliki government. It isn't the Maliki government that's going to save these people. It'll happen in the streets and the markets first. Once these people see that it's in their own advantage to keep the peace, they'll do it without having to be forced.
If we can give them the time ...
They will be given the time
August 14, 2007 - 13:59 ET by ThisnThatKC, President Bush is determined to give us the time. He will veto any and all bills that call for any time of pullout, and he will keep the strength in-country for the rest of his Presidency to ensure we have a chance for success. Everyone else is worried that we won't have a perfect report in September; I personally don't think this will be an issue at all.
Agreed
August 14, 2007 - 15:19 ET by KC MulvilleWe already know how the liberals will respond if Petraeus comes out with a report that doesn't advocate immediate withdrawal. They'll say that the military situation is going great, but the political situation is still bad - - and they'll point to Maliki's failures, and the Sunni boycotts, as evidence. We know that's their strategy because they've already said that's what they'll do: cf. Dick Durbin's comments on returning.
I was worried about the same thing a few weeks ago. But then, after a Newsbusters piece (forgive me, but I can't remember which one), I started reading the stories on what the surge is actually doing. I checked out a couple of the military blogs, and what they're reporting. It became more and more clear that Maliki is irrelevant. The surge is working out in the field, and that's what matters. Then came the report from the Brookings Institute guys last week, and it has become increasingly clear ... the surge is focusing on the people of Iraq, not the so-called leaders.
Now, I'm afraid of two things. One is an "anti-surge," where the terrorists think that a few spectacular bombings just before Petraeus' report will distract the media. The second is that the Democrats will exploit the weakness of the Maliki government as the "proof" that the surge really isn't working. Both of those strategies depend on distracting the media away from the on-the-ground reality of genuine progress. And what scares me is that the media will print it exactly as the terrorists and the Democrats present it.
But who knows? For all I know, Petraeus may come back and say, yeah, let's get the hell out of there. And if he does, and if he thinks this short burst of hope can't be sustained, fair enough. I just hope that whatever he reports, the media will give him a window to make his case, before steamrolling him with their own agenda.
outstanding insight KC. I
August 14, 2007 - 19:50 ET by contraryoutstanding insight KC. I predict your first scenario where Petraeus gives an overall good report on the surge and progress being made, but with some bad news as well. The Dems will highlight the bad to further their agenda, while the media will either be forced to report thr positive stories about Iraq, or just ignore the whole thing.
My predictions to Gen. P's
August 14, 2007 - 21:47 ET by Senior ChiefMy predictions to Gen. P's report will fall to "deaf" ears, since they've already declared the "war is already lost". I agree with Blonde's comments above, when are the Congressional Republicans and the administration starts pounding the leftoid media with their negative reporting. They cannot win the hearts of the conservative base if they just keep their mouth shut. To rally the base and lift the morale of my fellow warriors is to tell the truth- and tell all about the good news!
Thanks. Did you catch the
August 15, 2007 - 13:31 ET by KC MulvilleThanks. Did you catch the article today on Breitbart about Petraeus?
Well the Germans should know about being defeated by the US
August 14, 2007 - 14:07 ET by terrigIf anyone should take serious the verocity of the men and women that make up the US military it should be the Krauts. Sixty two years ago they were licking their wounds of defeat. That being said, I almost have to wonder if we'll see anything about this on "The pukedown with the strike out".
Wow - that good - Thanks Noel
August 14, 2007 - 14:15 ET by Dee BunkI had no idea things were going that good even from the alternative media! It's great - thanks for bringing the story Noel.
The US media would do well
August 14, 2007 - 14:38 ET by bassndudeThe US media would do well to take a lesson in objectivity from the Germans. Unlike the MSM, the Germans seem to be willing to look at the truth, and even more surprising, report it. How about that Dan Rather report what he thinks?
Save a SeAL, club a liberal!!
Jawohl!
August 14, 2007 - 15:02 ET by j17ghsDas ist nicht ein witz, ja?
However, it's Der Spiegel, and Demo-dummies will use it as proof positive that Bush is a Nazi! Clintons' scumbag campaign officials will slip it in to ads to scare urban communities, just wait and see.
(Republicans, of course, will do nothing and then wonder why we can't bother with them anymore and must go directly to the streets.)
Whew! What a read!
August 14, 2007 - 15:17 ET by JohnMQuite an impressive job of good, old-fashioned reporting. Thanks for the posting!
OK, the section titled "Old Lies Breed Skepticism" (just past mid-point) opens with this line:
"No one can forget how the hawks twisted the truth to engineer reasons to go to war..."
and based on the preceeding paragraphs, I fully expected to read the counter-point. However, the writer faithfully explores his topic.
Regardless of whether or not there were lies, I found myself coming back to complete the quote along the counter-point that I thought he was going toward:
"No one can forget how the hawks twisted the truth to engineer reasons to go to war..." and no one will forget how the media have twisted the truth to engineer reasons for withdrawing...
But that's just me.
I'd like to see us civilians parallel "the Surge" with our own re-surgence of support for the troops, by writing them letters and sending them our expressions of support. Send them reprints of the article, why not?
And above all, I urge us all to not relent, to not give in to the negativity of the majority of media we are assaulted by, but to remain steadfast in upholding our thoughts and prayers for an outcome that shows the world the goodness of the Iraqi people, and how much we want them to have and experience peace and freedom.
This article has shown me that my faith is not unfounded.
Shots from rifles and
August 14, 2007 - 17:03 ET by MidAmericaShots from rifles and pistols: zero.
We can't get that good of a report from an American city.
Yep...
August 15, 2007 - 07:50 ET by rbchaffeSounds like a good place to live, now.