If the surge in Iraq did not work, you can be sure the networks would all use its one-year anniversary to highlight its failure, but on Thursday night only ABC's World News, of the three broadcast network evening newscasts, marked the anniversary. With “Surge Success” on screen, anchor Charles Gibson noted “it was one year ago today that the surge began in Iraq -- the troop buildup ordered by the President when so many of his critics were calling for a draw down of troops. 30,000 additional troops started arriving a year ago.” From Iraq, Clarissa Ward began over matching video:
If you're looking for one measure of the impact of the surge, look at General David Petraeus, walking through a Baghdad neighborhood with no body armor and no helmet. It's one year since the beginning of what's known here as "Operation Fardh al-Qanoon." According to the U.S. military, violence is down 60 percent. One key to the success, reconciliation.
Ward proceeded to outline how residents of one Baghdad neighborhood “who had fled have flooded back in droves. "There is work," this mechanic told me. "Shops have reopened." But the Iraqi government has yet to capitalize on the relative peace. The hope is that the passing of the budget this week will spur the Iraqi government to act.”
Ward concluded with how Petraeus is “normally very guarded in his assessment of the surge,” but “now expresses cautious optimism.” Petraeus asserted: “I have to tell you that having been here for a number of years, this is very encouraging, actually. This is potentially a big moment.”
Thursday's CBS Evening News didn't have time for Iraq, but did make room for a five-minute long taped Katie Couric interview with Michelle Obama and the NBC Nightly News skipped the anniversary, but did end with a story on two-year old girl brought from Iraq (by Marines via a Tennessee church pastor) to Vanderbilt Hospital for a life-saving operation.
My February 13 NewsBusters item, “ABC Uniquely Lists 'Crucial' New Laws Passed by Iraq's Parliament,” recounted:
Unlike the Wednesday CBS and NBC evening newscasts, ABC's World News highlighted a favorable development in Iraqi political progress as anchor Charles Gibson gave 20 seconds to:
Overseas, in Iraq, a breakthrough for the country's government that has been so often criticized. Iraq's parliament approved three contentious, but crucial, new laws long sought by Washington. The laws set a budget for 2008, grant amnesty to thousands of detainees and define the relationship between the central government and the provinces.
Media interest in Iraq has declined as conditions have improved. The February 1 NewsBusters item by the MRC's Rich Noyes, “As U.S. Troops Succeed, Network News Retreats from Iraq War Story,” reported:
...over the last five months, the broadcast networks have consistently reduced their coverage of Iraq, as if the story of American success in Iraq is less worthy of attention than their old mantra of American failure in Iraq.
Media Research Center analysts tracked all coverage of the Iraq war on the ABC, CBS and NBC evening newscasts from September 1 through January 31, and we documented a steady decline in TV coverage of Iraq that has coincided with the improving situation in Iraq. Back in September, the three evening newscasts together broadcast 178 stories about the war in Iraq; in January, that number fell to just 47, a nearly fourfold decrease....
The MRC's Brad Wilmouth corrected the closed-captioning against the video to provide this transcript of the story on the February 14 World News with Charles Gibson on ABC:
CHARLES GIBSON: It was one year ago today that the surge began in Iraq -- the troop buildup ordered by the President when so many of his critics were calling for a draw down of troops. 30,000 additional troops started arriving a year ago. Most remain. For our "Closer Look" tonight, we take stock of a year's changes. And the U.S. commander, General David Petraeus, found a way to demonstrate the changes. Clarissa Ward reports from Baghdad.
CLARISSA WARD: If you're looking for one measure of the impact of the surge, look at General David Petraeus, walking through a Baghdad neighborhood with no body armor and no helmet. It's one year since the beginning of what's known here as "Operation Fardh al-Qanoon." According to the U.S. military, violence is down 60 percent. One key to the success, reconciliation.
GENERAL DAVID PETRAEUS: And a big part of the effort over the last year has been to determine who is reconcilable? Who literally is willing to put down his rifle and talk? Who is willing to shout instead of shoot?
WARD: This is the Jihad neighborhood of Baghdad. It used to be one of the most violent areas of the city. One year into Operation Fardh al-Qanoon, and that level has dropped dramatically. But there is still a desperate need to restore basic services. Before Shiite militiamen wreaked havoc in the streets. Then, U.S. and Iraqi troops moved into the neighborhood, earning the trust of local people, finding those men willing to put down their guns. In recent months, residents of Jihad who had fled have flooded back in droves. "There is work," this mechanic told me. "Shops have reopened." But the Iraqi government has yet to capitalize on the relative peace. The hope is that the passing of the budget this week will spur the Iraqi government to act.
PETRAEUS: So that they can start going about the jobs that are so essential, like patching the roads that we bounced down today, improving electricity, fixing water systems.
WARD: Normally very guarded in his assessment of the surge, the General now expresses cautious optimism.
PETRAEUS: I have to tell you that having been here for a number of years, this is very encouraging, actually. This is potentially a big moment.
WARD: A big moment the General wants to make the most of. Clarissa Ward, ABC News, Baghdad.
—Brent Baker is Vice President for Research and Publications at the Media Research Center





...over the last five months, the broadcast networks have consistently reduced their coverage of Iraq, as if the story of American success in Iraq is less worthy of attention than their old mantra of American failure in Iraq.
CLARISSA WARD: If you're looking for one measure of the impact of the surge, look at General David Petraeus, walking through a Baghdad neighborhood with no body armor and no helmet. It's one year since the beginning of what's known here as "Operation Fardh al-Qanoon." According to the U.S. military, violence is down 60 percent. One key to the success, reconciliation.
WARD: This is the Jihad neighborhood of Baghdad. It used to be one of the most violent areas of the city. One year into Operation Fardh al-Qanoon, and that level has dropped dramatically. But there is still a desperate need to restore basic services. Before Shiite militiamen wreaked havoc in the streets. Then, U.S. and Iraqi troops moved into the neighborhood, earning the trust of local people, finding those men willing to put down their guns. In recent months, residents of Jihad who had fled have flooded back in droves. "There is work," this mechanic told me. "Shops have reopened." But the Iraqi government has yet to capitalize on the relative peace. The hope is that the passing of the budget this week will spur the Iraqi government to act.













Editor at Large
Comments Policy
I say this cautiously, but
February 15, 2008 - 13:33 ET by Gary P JacksonI say this cautiously, but it seems ABC may have figured it out. Seems they've watched NBC and CBS fail miserably with their huge lib bias, and at least in part is trying to tell the truth. Good job!
WARD: Normally very guarded
February 15, 2008 - 13:53 ET by bigtimerWARD: Normally very guarded in his assessment of the surge, the General now expresses cautious optimism.
PETRAEUS: I have to tell you that having been here for a number of years, this is very encouraging, actually. This is potentially a big moment.
WARD: A big moment the General wants to make the most of. Clarissa Ward, ABC News, Baghdad.
...and if we were in a dem. administration there would of been bells and whistles on this anniversary on ALL the networks...simple as that.
I am glad ABC broadcast this, do not get me wrong, but the bias in the msm is past pathetic....they prove it with their intentional silence about the great work in Iraq..but if we have a huge suicide bombing...why that is usually 24/7 now isn't it?
I want to thank all of the military, the Pres. for sticking to his guns, and Gen Petraeus.
Miracles never cease
February 15, 2008 - 13:55 ET by greenfairieEven calling the surge a success is jaw-dropping.
# 1
February 15, 2008 - 16:53 ET by SupermanABC World News is the # 1 Newscast in America. I think I see why.
Typically American
February 15, 2008 - 17:08 ET by JustaPatriotGo figure, a uniquely American way to fight a war, buy your enemy to be your friend. Unfortunately paying $300(USD) a month to each insurgent is only as good as the money lasts. But heck, it beats paying $1000 a day per person to the likes of Blackwater....
I just have to add for those who haven’t looked back at G.W’s past jobs. True to form he is having someone pay cash to save his butt, to bad it couldn’t have been his dad and friends one more time instead of US
Those who fail to learn from History, are destined to repeat it.......
JustaPatriot, or JustaTroll
February 16, 2008 - 05:19 ET by HeikiWe are in fact already in Iraq, and must look at a variety of ways to quell a persistent insurgency. A major factor in this insurgency is joblessness; explain how providing funds to neighborhood watch type programs is counterproductive, and better yet, please elaborate on your contention that Blackwater receives $1K per day per person for their support in Iraq. It's easy to throw out KBR/Blackwater/Bush/Rove/Cheney grenades without supporting data. Nice try, though.
The Iraq campaign will be the defining geopolitical maneuver of the next hundred years for U.S. security interests abroad, and unless we give up and go home, will result in a huge strategic plus for the security of the U.S. in the long term. I truly believe that the Iraqi people can be brought out of the darkness that has engulfed them for the last several decades, and that they will be a strong force for moderation and modernization in the region and even the larger Islamic world, presuming we don't abandon them. Drop the 24/7 news cyle mentality and look at the Big Picture. They need us, and we need them, to forment a safer, more rational world.
I agree with you 100
February 16, 2008 - 15:55 ET by JustaPatriotI agree with you 100 percent Heiki that an insurgency multiplies in an environment where the populace is not working. Make work programs along with medical and basic construction needs are at the heart of any plan to win over the locals. I believe that was tried and no one took the bait. Only when we started paying for the “neighborhood security” did we see a positive change in the locals. Speaking of grenades, your way understating the “neighborhood watch type” programs here. At first it was assault rifles and some ammunition, but as these groups started attacking al Qaeda, and not attacking us, we stepped up with more weapons, ammunitions, radios night gear and CASH directly to them. Certainly the current Iraqi government does not sanction the paying let alone the forming of these security forces in Sunni dominated areas for the obvious reasons. We can only hope that the Iraqi government can negotiate with these tribesmen to bring them into the political process
Interestingly when I go to government sites for documentation, when it comes to daily rates, they are so far always blacked out, with just gross figures being available. As a comparison, some documents mention about 3 months worth of pay equals a years pay in the States. From a book review of Jeremy Scahill’s titled “Blackwater” the reviewer mentions the $1000 a day figure. There is also a great frontline documentary that you should watch titled Private Warriors which also brings up about paying up to $1000 a day. If we had the basics of our constitutional democracy “oversight and openness” we would all know the real facts
Again I agree that the war in Iraq will certainly be a defining geopolitical maneuver for the next Hundred years that the U.S. will have to deal with, and I certainly hope you are correct. your statement
" I truly believe that the Iraqi people can be brought out of the darkness that has engulfed them for the last several decades, and that they will be a strong force for moderation and modernization in the region and even the larger Islamic world..."
is a very magnanimous statement worthy of a great democracy. Unfortunately that wasn't even close to any reason given to us to go to war against Iraq. The view that I see from following our government for a long time is we have been put in a quagmire by the current administration, that they only thought of the big picture without a inkling about how to get us to that end, and that is an impeachable offence....
Those who fail to learn from History, are destined to repeat it.......
The Big Picture
February 16, 2008 - 21:05 ET by HeikiJustaPatriot: Like I said, this issue needs to be looked at in the long term. GWB, along with most members of congress and virtually every intelligence agency consulted all thought that Saddam was a major WMD threat and that was the justification for invading Iraq when it was initiated. The president simply wasn't going to take the risk of Saddam aiding our Islamofascist enemies by providing them with WMD assets/assistance in a post-911 world. ''Not on my watch'' is the angle here and is certainly therefore not impeachable. Believe you me, if there were in fact grounds to impeach this president, it would have been done already. Regardless of the information and events that led us into Iraq, the fact remains that we are already there, and the only course of action at this point that will positively serve our security interests is to ensure that Iraq becomes a stablizing, example-setting force for good in Southwest Asia and the greater Islamic world. ''Sorry Achmed, I'd love to join your Jihad, but I've gotta go to work; I'm still paying off the new truck, and the wife just had a new kitchen installed. Good luck with that, though.'' When Iraq's neighbors see Iraqis living in relative peace and harmony, freely electing their leaders and building instead of destroying, I believe it will create a sea-change in Islamic attitude throughout the world and hopefully lead to a reformation of that religion. Call me a hopeless optimist if you will, but the alternative is unthinkable: a long-term war with a billion of the globe's inhabitants that, sooner or later, WILL involve WMD's, likely on U.S. soil. If overthrowing Iraq's government and instituting a stable democracy in the heart of the Middle East can accomplish that, it will have been worth it, original reason for invading notwithstanding. Three thousand (and counting) of our people's lives have been spent, and they'll only have been wasted if we give up and go home.
Sucess in Iraq admitted by the MSM???
February 15, 2008 - 17:11 ET by SFCMACWow, I'm suprised ABC even admitted such a thing. I'm going to have to mark this on my calendar.
"On the Eighth Day God Created the United States Army and the Devil Stood at Attention"